
We've Been Here The Whole Time! A Not So Sacred Guide to All Things Native America
Season 31 Episode 44 | 56m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
A Conversation with Joey Clift, Author, Comedian, TV writer, and Producer
We’ve Been Here The Whole Time! A Not So Sacred Guide to All Things Native America is a funny and deeply informative comedy satire book about Native American history and modern issues likely left out of your high school's lesson plans.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
The City Club Forum is a local public television program presented by Ideastream

We've Been Here The Whole Time! A Not So Sacred Guide to All Things Native America
Season 31 Episode 44 | 56m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
We’ve Been Here The Whole Time! A Not So Sacred Guide to All Things Native America is a funny and deeply informative comedy satire book about Native American history and modern issues likely left out of your high school's lesson plans.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch The City Club Forum
The City Club Forum is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipProduction and distribution of City Club Forums by Ideastream Public Media are made possible by PNC and Nordson Corporation.
Good afternoon, and welcome to the City Club of Cleveland.
We are devoted to conversations of consequence that help democracy thrive.
It's Friday, November 13th, and I'm Cynthia Connolly, Senior Director of Programming here.
And what a privilege it is to introduce to all of you Joey Clift, Peabody and 2-time Emmy Award-nominated comedian, Director, Producer, and Author of his newest book, We've Been Here The Whole Time!
A Not So Sacred Guide to All Things Native America.
A round of applause, please, everybody.
Joey.
Thank you, everybody.
Thank you.
Yeah, you're good.
When I first learned of this book, it was described to me as what would happen if the writers' room of The Onion and The Daily Show wrote a book about Native America.
Yes.
And Marvel Universe actor Mark Ruffalo, who plays the Hulk, blurbed Joey's book, and he's endearingly known in Native circles as Uncle Hulk.
So I was very excited to see that.
We've Been Here the Whole Time!
walks you through a wide range of misconceptions, weird questions, and even weirder assumptions, covering everything from Pocahontas and sports mascots to ancestry claims and the Land Back movement.
More on all of this here shortly.
Joey Clift is an enrolled member of the Cowlitz Indian Tribe located in Washington State and has written a lot of TV shows you've probably heard of.
Paw Patrol on Nickelodeon, Spirit Rangers on Netflix, Molly of Denali on PBS Kids.
Shout out to our friends at Ideastream Public Media.
And he has also written for comedy outlets like Dropout, Comedy Central, and Cracked.
I actually met -- first met Joey here in Cleveland at the 2025 Cleveland International Film Festival.
He was screaming his -- or screening his animated short film Pow!
No screaming involved, which hilariously follows a Native kid as he scrambles to charge his dying video game console at a powwow.
And now he's back in Cleveland once again, making us laugh with his latest book.
He's coming equipped with a list of who is and isn't invited to that powwow.
Uncle Hulk, for example, invited to the powwow.
A reminder for our livestream and radio audience: if you have a question during the Q&A portion of the forum, you can text it to 330-541-5794, and City Club staff will try to work it into the program.
Now, members and friends of the City Club of Cleveland, please join me in welcoming Joey Clift.
So the last time we had a a Native author and historian here.
It was Ned Blackhawk.
He was the author of the Indigenous history of the United States from the Native perspective, right?
His book was a tome, lots of footnotes, super deep.
I think it was 500 years it was spanning.
This is not that, correct?
This is not that kind of book.
Oh, yeah, for sure.
Yeah.
All respect to Ned Blackhawk.
He is more of a scholar.
I'm a guy who my biggest credit is writing for a show where dogs drive cars.
So let's just say I don't go that deep.
Yeah, and so I think Shane Hawke, he's the co-editor of the amazing book Never Whistle at Night.
He provided the foreword for this book.
If you haven't read that book as well, Never Whistle at Night, it's a horror movie, or -- Yeah, Never Whistle at Night, it's a dark fiction anthology with like all Indigenous authors.
The audiobook is great for Never Whistle at Night too.
It features Lily Gladstone voicing a character, so I definitely recommend it.
Yeah, he said this book isn't a lecture.
It is a ride.
So can you take us through how you structured that book?
What kind of ride are we looking at?
So the goal of this book was to be a very accessible way to kind of get educated about Native history, Native people, and contemporary Native culture.
And I didn't want to start this book with like, you know, the beginning of the book takes place in the 1400s and the end of the book takes place in present day.
I wanted to structure it as a comedian, as kind of a comedy show.
So like I structured the book where each -- there are 4 sections and each book starts and covers like levels of different complexity as far as, you know, education about Native issues goes.
So like literally the first chapter of the book is called Wait a Second, Aren't Native People Extinct?
With the length of that chapter being just the text, no, stop asking that question.
And we get that question a lot.
Oh yeah, for sure.
That's a real question.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And then I thought you guys were extinct.
Yeah.
And it's like, nope, I have a job.
Like, still here.
Yeah, for sure.
For sure.
And then the second section goes into more of the basics, things like Native sports mascots.
The third section is a little bit more advanced, going into things like, you know, tribal casinos.
And the fourth section goes into like sort of issues that Native people are dealing with today.
And one of the things that I'm very proud about with this book is one of the last pages is your very own Indian 101 diploma, which after reading this book, it shows that you got a basic knowledge of Native issues.
And I really wanted to structure the book where like there's long info-dumpy chapters that, you know, give a lot of information about different complex issues.
But there are also a lot of really short, fun, punchy chapters.
Like, one of my favorites is a chapter called A Complete List of People You Can Call Pocahontas Without Being Racist, with number 1 being the actual Pocahontas, whose name was Matoaka, 2, Disney's Pocahontas, 3 -- there is no 3.
That's the whole list.
And you have a lot of these fun lists throughout your book.
It's kind of broken up between these fun flowcharts.
You have quizzes.
There's like an office quiz where you can find your spirit animal.
And I'm not going to give away the hook here, but it's -- It's very clever how you broke that up.
I know you have one that's a list -- wait, if you own a dreamcatcher, do you suck?
And so you can actually find out if owning a dreamcatcher is something you can and cannot do.
Yeah, for sure.
That is in particular a flowchart that I'm very proud of.
There's also a flowchart answering the question of when is it okay to touch a Native person's hair, with the only yes answers being, are you a barber and did they ask you for a haircut?
And 2, do they have like a bee stuck in their hair and you touching it's the only way to get the bee out?
Other than that, maybe don't touch a random stranger's hair.
Yeah, the dreamcatcher one made me laugh only because the one thing I will say is missing from the flowchart is, is it hanging in the rearview mirror of your car?
Yeah, it doesn't go there.
Yeah, for sure.
That's so funny to me that people will buy a dreamcatcher and hang it in the rearview mirror of their car because like, what, are you sleeping while driving?
Taking a nap on 71 Northgate?
Yeah, sure, sure.
Yeah.
You know, and I think it's also interesting that, you know, you're a comedian, so naturally you lean towards humor and comedy.
But there's a lot of Native humor around that a lot of people aren't aware of.
You know, we had our first TV shows come out, Reservation Dogs, Rutherford Falls.
Yeah, give those a round of applause.
Fantastic shows.
And I've had people say, oh, I'm surprised they, you know, you guys picked comedy as your first, like, content.
I'm like, I'm not surprised at all.
We're really funny.
So, you know, tell me a little bit about, you know, why you chose comedy in particular for this book, for history about Native people.
Yeah, I guess it's no surprise for me for people to ask that question, because I mean, I feel like for most people, their main touchstone of Native people that they know is a Native person crying when they see garbage on the ground, which, by the way, the guy who played that Native character in that PSA was an Italian guy.
He was born in Sicily.
Yeah, true story.
Yeah, shout out to Iron Eyes Cody.
I get what the opposite of a shout out to Iron Eyes Cody.
But yeah, if you go to any rez, if you hang out with Native folks, you're going to hear a lot of jokes and a lot of laughter.
I mean, it's not weird to be at a powwow and hear somebody say the most brutal roast joke you've ever heard in your life, followed by ayyy to show that they're just kidding.
And it was more -- it was really important to me in writing this book and really like in a lot of the work that I do in my career to make sure that I'm showcasing Native joy and showcasing that like, we're not all stoic folks who are looking off into the distance while an eagle caws and you hear flute music.
We're funny too.
And I feel like comedy is a great medium for this as well.
I mean, comedy often uses the painfully obvious to point out the truth, right?
And your book does that expertly, like from, you know, are Native people extinct to the, the deepness of the boarding school era, for example.
Yeah, for sure.
I mean, the book is called A Not So Sacred Guide to All Things Native America.
And for me, like, it was important that I covered a lot of the, you know, the basic questions that people have, like, you know, covering topics like Thanksgiving, Pocahontas, and a lot of stuff like that.
But I feel like with it being called A Not So Sacred Guide to All Things Native America, it would be really disingenuous if I didn't cover, you know, the tragic stuff, things like you mentioned, boarding schools, attempted genocide.
You know, the like the murder missing indigenous women epidemic, and I definitely part of the part of the job as a comedy writer for this book for writing a book that primarily you know features jokes and you're intended to laugh while reading was how do I how do I thread that needle and how do I cover those really deep subjects while also kind of trying to keep things light?
And for those particular chapters, I tried to be as like.
Respectful and joke-light as possible and really trying to, you know, honor the, you know, the tragic experience of a lot of the people that experienced those systems.
So, but so the way that I kind of measure that is like the boarding school chapter, for example, you know, is a really emotional chapter.
Like, I cried while writing it.
Like, a lot of people have told me they've cried while reading it.
But immediately after that, the next chapter is literally just a doodle of Deb Haaland kicking Christopher Columbus in the nuts.
Followed by a chapter about how great Deb Haaland is.
So a little palate cleanser.
Yeah, for sure.
So I guess I really wanted to make sure, you know, as a comedian, that I was taking care of the audience throughout this process in the same way that you would for a comedy show, making sure that I'm like picking the jokes in the right places.
And whenever there's a moment of heaviness, making sure that I'm allowing some, some moment of joy at some point, you know, afterwards.
And you've done that for other topics throughout your career too.
I know I remember some years ago you released an animated short about being a pretendian and something about, you know, being -- calling yourself a Native when you're not Native is like calling yourself a bear when you're not a bear.
And it's a really funny short.
Oh, yeah, for sure.
That was actually the first piece that I ever wrote that was specifically using comedy to tackle Native issues.
It came out in 2018.
And the short -- the full title of the short is Telling People You're Native American When You're Not Native Is a Lot Like Telling a Bear You're a Bear When You're Not a Bear.
The title is 24 words long, basically a Fiona Apple album title of a short film title if there ever I try my best.
Oh yeah, for sure.
Oh, like when I wrote, when I wrote the short and came up with the title for it, I didn't think that I or other people would have to say it very often.
It's great though.
Yeah, when it's, it's been shared at this point, like I think around 10 million times across social media.
It got featured by, you know, NPR and a lot of other great places.
And, um, like that, seeing the positive response of that and how like there are literally schools that have told like professors, you know, everybody from middle school to high school to college, telling me that they've used that short as part of their curriculums from now on when teaching Native issues.
And that for me was a real, like, lightbulb moment of, oh, not only are people really excited to see Native comedy, they're also really excited to see Native or see comedy being used as a way to tackle Native issues in a real substantive way.
And for the record, for the non-Natives in the room, pretendian is short for pretend Indian.
Like Johnny Depp is a pretendian.
That's just an example, I'll say.
Yeah.
And so I want to get in a little bit about some of the knowledge gap we were talking about a little earlier.
A 2018 study by Reclaiming Native Truth, an organization formerly known as IllumiNative, they've now rebranded into Indigenous House, which is a fantastic org focused on increasing representation of Native people in film and media.
They did a massive research study, one of the first of its kind to actually survey Native people on the rez, off the rez, across hundreds of different tribes.
I think they got over 5,000 respondents.
It was quite comprehensive.
They said that nearly half of Americans believed what they were taught in schools about Native Americans was inaccurate.
72% thought it was necessary to make significant changes to their curriculum of Native history.
Something the non-Natives they surveyed, they also found that 2/3 of Native Americans -- or 2/3 of Americans think they don't think they met a Native person.
So 2/3 of this country don't even interact with Native people.
And one of our favorites is that 87% of K through 12 schools don't even talk about Native Americans after the year 1900.
These are really heavy stats when you talk about it.
There's some disenfranchisement over what they're being taught and not being taught in school.
Vast underrepresentation of basic knowledge of Native people.
Is that one of the reasons that you opted to write this book?
Yeah, for sure.
That research study you mentioned came out in 2018.
For me, a big inspiration for this book is just the experiences that I have had conversing with non-Natives throughout my life.
I'm enrolled Cowlitz and I grew up on the Tulalip Reservation, which is about 45 minutes north of Seattle.
And I went to tribally run schools.
I mean, I'm Native, so from a Native family, just surrounded by other Native people.
I feel like I had a really great base level knowledge of Native people and Native issues growing up.
And when I went to college across the state, it was my first time interacting with non-Native people who, as far as they know, had never met another or never met a Native person before.
And I immediately was asked just insane questions.
Like, I remember a freshman asking me, the question, why do you get to vote in our elections?
And I was like, what?
I'm a college student.
Why are you asking me this?
You know, questions like if I was born in a teepee, which I was born in Washington, it would have been a longhouse.
Also, I was born in the '80s, so it was a hospital.
You know, questions like if I have magic powers, which I don't.
Cynthia does.
Don't tell anybody.
Super sacred.
Yeah, for sure.
Super sacred.
Flute music, eagle cry.
You get it.
And It really showed me, like, when this research study came out showing, you know, putting numbers to just the wild questions that I and a lot of my friends have been asked in my life, it really illuminated like, oh, this is not just, you know, an issue that I deal with.
This is like a systemic thing that's caused by just this huge knowledge gap of what people don't know about Native people and what they wish that they knew.
So for me, I mean, seeing the resources that are out there to get educated about this stuff, it's often like very thick history textbooks that are written very academically, or things that are ultra-focused on our trauma.
So with this book, I really wanted to lean into my comedy background and write something that is an accessible way that you can read and get educated about all this stuff in something that you can read in like an afternoon.
I think the audiobook is like 4 hours long, and you can laugh along the way while doing it.
And I think that just a way to solve that knowledge gap is to make this information just a little bit more accessible for people.
Yeah, I also was asked my senior year in high school if I grew up on a reservation.
Mind you, this was from a student that I went to school with since preschool.
Yeah, yeah.
And I was like, I live around the block from you, like, what do you mean?
So it's like, I think, a very universal kind of moment for a lot of Native people when they pick up your book.
I mean, I was wondering what the reception was by Native people as they read it, because for me it was a kind of an affirmation.
It was almost cathartic.
Reading it?
Because all these things that you touch on, I've been asked, my family, colleagues, you know, it's -- I'm wondering how other Native people have received your book.
Well, that's been something that's been so cool to see about the reception of this book.
It came out October 6th, so like a little bit over a month ago.
And I have gotten a lot of really great responses from, you know, non-Native folks who have told me that this book just really opened their eyes and educated them about Native issues in a really easy-to-digest way.
And then Native folks telling me exactly what you said, which is like, oh, it's just really cathartic to see somebody like roasting and making fun of and cracking jokes about all these things that we just experience, you know, on a regular basis.
And a big goal of mine with this book is, you know, we are asked so many weird questions by non-Native people who just don't really know any better.
And I really wanted this to be something that can hopefully like raise the bar so that you're not asked if you grew up on a reservation by somebody in high school so that We don't have to, like, educate somebody on how we feel about, you know, dreamcatchers, for example.
I joke in the book that this is a really great passive-aggressive gift to any of your coworkers who refer to meetings as powwows.
And that's actually -- that's been something that's been really cool to see as I've done a lot of events on my tour is there are a lot of people, specifically Native folks, who have walked up to me with like a stack of 5 books that they purchased to sign.
And they said like, this is for my boss, this one's for my coworker.
And I'm like, oh, got it, got it, got it.
I see you.
I see what you're doing.
And I think it's also good for this, for non-Natives to only -- I'm speaking just wearing my hat organizing for the local Native community here in Cleveland.
Often, we're engaged as a community at really finite moments in the year.
Thanksgiving is one of them.
Happy November, everybody.
Native American Heritage Month.
Happy Native Month.
I actually broke all the rules that I set for myself in booking you in November, because I'm like, I'm not going to book Natives in November.
It is Heritage Month.
Let's talk about Natives any other time of the year.
But I mean, your book came out this month, so by default, I think we're okay.
Yeah, this is -- one, you get a pass because you're Native, and it's like, we could do it, it doesn't count.
And two, yeah, my book -- I'm in the middle of my book tour, so I just happen to have a lot of events this month.
So it's okay, you don't have to feel bad, it's fine.
But it's also -- yeah, but it's also like, back when we had the mascot here, opening day, we were tapped then, and then Columbus Day, and then that's it.
There was no more engagement.
Yeah, we don't exist the rest of the year.
We disappear.
No, it's those moments, right?
And so this book really fills in those gaps and helps encourage people to think of Native people beyond just what you're used to hearing.
And I appreciate that.
Well, yeah, I mean, I mentioned earlier, it's like, I mean, one of the things -- so the diploma that I mentioned at the end of the book that you get after reading the book, one of the things that I say in it is like, by signing this diploma, I promise that I will book Native people all year round and not only in November.
All year round.
Yeah, for sure.
Or like not reach out only during November.
So please drop me a message in my inbox any other time of the year, please.
When it's the worst, just to, just to gripe for a second, it's the worst because I feel like oftentimes those asks around Thanksgiving, they're usually not asked very far in advance.
It's usually like I'll get an email in my inbox like the, like the day before Thanksgiving.
It's also a very short month because of the holidays.
Yeah, for sure.
So like if, if I get an ask do something in November, but somebody asks me in like May, I'm like, oh, you're being courteous of my schedule.
You know, can we -- speaking of like inboxes, can we talk about land acknowledgments?
Oh yeah, let's do it.
Yeah, because I get like probably once, at least once a week, I get somebody asking me and I'm like, I know what land we're standing on.
It seems like a you problem.
Yeah, this seems like a thing that you could Google for sure.
I also got to say, you don't get bonus points for asking a Native person to do a land acknowledgment.
And additionally, if you ask somebody whose tribe is, you know, their Aboriginal territory that the land is on that you want to be acknowledged, you're essentially asking them to acknowledge themselves, which is super weird.
Maybe don't do that.
I mean, main character a little bit, but like, just, yeah, maybe do the work.
Yeah, for sure.
One of the things I joke about in the book is that land acknowledgments are great, but you know what's even better?
Actually helping Native people.
Yeah, that'd be great.
I want to do -- I want to take it back a little bit to your own personal journey in film and media.
I mean, obviously, we have the Crew Foundation here doing amazing work at increasing representation of particularly BIPOC folks in film and media production.
Yeah, give it up for the Crew Foundation.
Yeah, good job, Crew.
Sheila, talk a little bit about your journey.
Now, you had such a great repertoire -- Paw Patrol, Molly of Denali, which my kids absolutely loved.
And just incredible to have that representation in kids' TV shows, which I didn't have growing up.
Talk a little bit about what it was like to start and maybe the journey to today and where you're at today.
Yeah, for sure.
So my story is that growing up on the Tulalip rez, I loved comedy shows like The Simpsons, Family Guy, Conan O'Brien, and things like that.
But because I didn't see any Native comedians on the TV shows I watched as a kid, I didn't think I was allowed to work in comedy.
So instead, I went to school for what to me felt like the next best thing, and that was to be a small market TV weather guy.
That's right, early comedy hero Al Roker, I guess.
And fortunately, when I went to college to pursue that as a career, a bunch of my professors pulled me aside and gave me the very obvious advice of, hey, you could work in TV news, but you know you could also work in comedy, right?
And I was like, what?
That's an option?
So this was around 2010.
I moved to Los Angeles, dove into the LA comedy scene with both feet, places like the Upright Citizens Brigade Theater, Second City, the Groundlings, and worked my way up writing for a lot of the shows that you mentioned earlier, things like Looney Tunes, Ninjago, Shrek, PAW Patrol.
And I really have made it my goal throughout my career to try to create the work that gives folks kind of the permission to dream that I wish I had as a kid.
And I think in the stories that I tell, specifically in the kids space, I'm working really hard to try to create like the sorts of characters and TV shows that I wish I had when I was a kid.
And what's so cool about that is like shows like Molly of Denali, you know, Spirit Rangers.
I'm not the only Native person working on those shows.
We have teams of like hundreds of Native folks who are on those shows.
And we all have the same mission.
We all understand the homework assignment of we're trying to undo a century, if not centuries, of bad Native representation in media by trying to create those cool, good, just like Native AF stories that we wish we had.
And I feel like there is a shift happening right now in terms of representation in film and media, particularly on the production side, in part because of creators like yourself.
And, you know, we're seeing more and more folks take up space in rooms where we weren't always welcome, or if we were there, maybe ignored.
And so it's, you know, tell me a little bit about some of the other folks that you're seeing rise up in these spaces.
Well, yeah, for sure.
That is something that is so cool to see about what's happening right now is like there aren't just, you know, Native writers and actors.
Doing the work.
There are Native, like, directors of photography.
There's fantastic Native directors.
There's folks like, you know, like Sterlin Harjo, the creator of Reservation Dogs and The Lowdown, is, you know, doing really great work.
People like Tazbah Chavez, who's directing the NBC series The Paper, which is like a really fantastic series that kind of takes place in the greater Ohio area.
You know, Carissa Valencia was the creator of Spear Rangers, and she's a member of the Chumash tribe and just a genius kids' TV writer who I was so blessed to work with, like Vera Starbard on Molly of Denali.
It really does feel like, you know, it is still a fairly small community in terms of the whole entertainment industry.
We call Native Hollywood sort of the loose collection of Native folks who work in the entertainment industry.
And there's maybe like 500 of us.
But it is so cool to see that these are 500 people who, like, have credits, who've worked on big productions and are, you know, excited and ready to take on more opportunities.
And, you know, you mentioned like Rutherford Falls, Reservation Dogs, and Spirit Rangers, the show I worked on, and Molly of Denali.
As like really great sort of flashpoints in Native representation.
But what's so cool about the hundreds of Native folks who've worked on those shows is we're all like spider-webbing out and working on our own projects and other productions right now in a way that's really cool to see.
If I recall, Reservation Dogs too, they were able to essentially train folks in production.
If I remember, like they were actually bringing folks over into the rez and training them on videography.
In cinematography, film editing, things like that.
And so it almost birthed a new generation of Joey Clifts.
Oh, thanks.
Yeah.
Scary.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Thanks.
Thanks so much for bringing that up.
And yeah, I mean, that is something that is so cool to see is it feels like this generation of creatives working in the entertainment industry, we all really have the same mindset of like, we need to reach our hand down, pull up the generation that's going to be behind us You know, we need to pull people up alongside us in the line.
We need to, you know, give opportunities to folks and, you know, really understand that, like, it's not like there's been an ocean of Native folks who have been given mainstream opportunities in the entertainment industry up until really just the past couple of years.
So the folks of us who have our foot in the door are really doing what we can to, like, mentor and give opportunities and, you know, train and, you know, recommend a lot of other folks to try to kind of, you know, make it so that like it's the 7 generations principle, right?
So that like it's not just about our generation, it's not about just about our success.
It's about setting up the next 7 generations of like Native storytellers in a way that it's just really like cool to see.
Yeah.
And I think one really neat moment too, particularly in your book, is, you know, with the heavy -- you have this one theme actually.
Let me bring this up first.
The folks who are not invited to the powwow.
So peppered through the book are a series of individuals with an interesting history that absolutely will not be invited to the powwow.
But you counter that, right?
It's easy to get into this deficit narrative when talking about Native people and Native history in particular, right?
Because there is a great deal of trauma and heaviness to it.
But you also bring in Native excellence and highlight some really dope people doing cool stuff.
In Native America.
Yeah, it was really important to me that this book isn't just a book that's, you know, dunking on colonizers and talking about like weird microaggressions Native folks experience.
I really wanted to use this book as an opportunity to highlight really great recent Native history as well as really awesome Native folks doing great work out there.
So I mentioned earlier there's an entire chapter about all the accomplishments of Deb Haaland.
I have an entire chapter about how great Lily Gladstone is.
Uh, Native woman elected to governor.
Yeah, right.
United States.
Yeah, that's awesome, right?
Also shout out to Peggy Flanagan, the first Native woman elected to the Senate.
That's great.
Earrings though.
Yeah, right.
Oh yeah, big beaded earrings.
Yeah, well, that is something that -- so we were talking about this in the green room earlier -- that's so cool about like all these Native folks being elected to like prominent public office positions is they're really like indigenizing the space.
Like Deb Haaland, um, when she was, uh, named, um, the Secretary of the Interior, she wore like a ribbon skirt to her ceremony.
And you mentioned -- yeah, when she was a rep too, she, uh, for the first State of the Union, she saved her seat in the chambers with a Pendleton blanket, right?
Like, that's what we do at powwow.
Like, you show up and you're like, this is mine, and you put your blanket down.
Nobody messes with it.
Like, you've claimed it.
Um, and she did that in chambers, and that was like a huge moment for Native people.
Like, we see ourselves in the chambers.
Yeah, on the, on the, the, the less cool version of that.
But when we were working on Spirit Rangers, we had an all-Native writers' room, which I was a part of, and we convinced Netflix to give us Indigenous Peoples' Day off every year.
And then we went to the park and ate Indian tacos.
So it's like, I actually -- my tradition is I eat Indian food from India because that's where Columbus thought he landed.
I was like, well, I have to go eat Indian food.
Right, right, right.
But yeah, so it was really important for me to use the book as a way to kind of not just dunk on colonizers, but also to elevate the great work of a lot of fantastic Native folks and to highlight, like, also our contributions to, you know, some really great things in history.
Like, I have an entire chapter called You're Welcome for Space Travel, where I highlight all the amazing accomplishments of Native folks in aerospace.
You know, I talk about the fact that the U.S.
system of government was essentially lifted from the Haudenosaunee Confederacy.
It was really important to me to, you know, use this as an opportunity to educate people about, you know, microaggressions and things like that, but also to, like, basically highlight, like, here's cool Native stuff that everybody should know.
Like, we do so much cool stuff.
And actually, I want to bring it back to the aerospace conversation, um, because you mentioned Aaron Yazzie in your book, who I actually know quite well.
He actually interned at NASA Glenn here in Cleveland, and he -- yes, a round of applause.
And yeah, my husband Joe is here.
He works at NASA as well and knew Aaron.
And so I got super excited seeing him in the book.
And tell me, retell that story.
It's such a good story about his representation in Spirit Rangers in particular.
Okay, so Spirit Rangers, a show that I worked on, it was the first kids' show in the history of US animation created by a Native person.
I mentioned Chris Valencia earlier, with an all-Native writers' room.
And in working on that show for Netflix, we really wanted to use the show as a means to, I guess I would say, like, elevate our heroes as much as we can, to really highlight so many cool Native folks doing great work.
And I remember when the show was announced, Aaron Yazzie, he retweeted the show announcement saying something to the effect of like, you know, I love my job at Aerospace.
I love that I, you know, build drill bits for the Mars rovers, but I wish I could write a kids' show where a bunch of Native kids go to space.
And I screencapped that tweet and had it on my desktop for probably a year or two.
And then once we hit a point working on Spirit Rangers where Carissa, the show's creator, mentioned, hey, we should do like a space episode, I immediately pulled up that tweet and I was like, yes, and we should have Aaron Yazzie in it and have him play himself.
So we had an animated Aaron Yazzie, this aerospace engineer who's a member of the Navajo Nation who works at NASA, show up.
He's actually nicknamed Native Bill Nye.
Like, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Not even joking.
Like, we had him show up as like, he's like the dad of Spirit Ranger's friend from college, and it's It's like it's treated like it's like a celebrity guest on the show where it's just like, everybody, Aaron Yazhi's here!
And, you know, I, I asked him to, um, you know, I, I Twitter DM'd him once Netflix okayed it to ask him to do it, and he was like, of course I would love to be a cartoon character.
I felt like Leonardo DiCaprio, that Leonardo DiCaprio meme where he's like pointing at the screen aggressively, because when they -- yeah, because my kids were watching it and up like walks cartoon Aaron Yazhi, and I almost fell out of my chair.
It was great.
Well, yeah, when that, that That's what I was talking about, where it's sort of -- I mean, for a really long time, history and American culture have not really spotlighted or elevated the accomplishments of a lot of really exceptional Native folks.
And I kind of figure with my position in the work that I do, it's like, if I and my generation doesn't do it, who else is going to do it?
So I think it's really important for us to point at somebody like Aaron Yazzie and say, this guy is impressive, and his work is changing science.
So we should acknowledge that and honor that through the stories that we tell.
Absolutely.
All right.
And we are going to move to the audience Q&A.
For those just joining via our livestream and radio audience, I'm Cynthia Connolly, Senior Director of Programming.
And I'm here at the City Club of Cleveland, joined on stage by Joey Clift, Peabody and 2-time Emmy-nominated TV writer, comedian, director, producer, and author of We've Been Here The Whole Time!
A Not So Sacred Guide to All Things Native America.
That's a lot of titles.
I love that for you.
So great.
I do too much.
Yes, you do all of the things.
We welcome questions from everybody -- City Club members, guests, students, and those joining via our livestream at cityclub.org or our live radio broadcast at 89.7 WKSU Ideastream Public Media.
This is a text question that we received as you guys were talking.
I'm interested in hearing about your short film, Pow!
How did you go about finding an animator, and can you talk about the process of directing an artist?
Yeah, for sure.
Thanks so much for asking that question.
And Poww is an animated short film that I released last year that's about a young Native kid trying to find a place to charge his video game console at a powwow.
It's kind of like Looney Tunes meets Reservation Dogs is the way that I pitch it.
And I made it around 2024, spent about a year working on it.
And fortunately, I'm in a position, you know, as somebody who's worked in the entertainment industry for 15, 16 years, where I have a lot of really talented people that are just kind of, you know, in my Rolodex, people that I've worked with over the years.
I want to specifically shout out the character designer and then somebody who also helped with animation and storyboards, Morgan Thompson.
She's a member of the Cherokee Nation, and she's, I think, the first Native person to ever win an Annie Award, which is basically like the Emmys for specifically animation.
And she's like 27, so she's very talented.
It was really important for me to have a lot of Native folks working on this production.
It has an all-Native cast.
You know, we have Morgan as the character designer.
We brought in a lot of the Spirit Rangers team to compose and do sound design for the short.
And then we also had a lot of really great non-Native allies working on the short, specifically an animation production company called Flicker Lab that I've worked with a lot over the years.
And they're fantastic.
They've worked with everybody from like, from like Stephen Colbert to Michael Moore.
And yeah, I guess that with, with any kind of animation idea, it's like you start with the idea and kind of go from there.
So this was a short that I've wanted to make for a couple of years, and then I fortunately got some really great funding support from an organization called Pop Culture Collaborative.
And once I had that piece in place, then I reached out to Morgan, who's somebody that I just like met at a Native Hollywood party, and we followed each other on Instagram and I saw that her art was really fantastic.
And then once we had that in place, I reached out to the animation production company and then it just kind of snowballs from there.
It's like, and we probably had a team of, I want to say, 30 to 40 people who worked on Pow!
And I'm so proud of it.
You can watch the whole short for free on FNX TV.
And we actually, I think as of this month, officially got distributed by AMC+, which is really cool.
And we actually qualified for the Oscars last year in the Best Animated Short category, which is nuts.
So definitely check that short out.
But yeah, thanks so much for that question.
Can you speak a little bit on what it was like making that switch into the entertainment industry and kind of those early days of becoming a writer, becoming a comedian, and what that process was like?
Yeah, for sure.
So I, for a long time, mentioned -- I mentioned earlier, I thought that my career path was going to take me to, you know, working in a newsroom, being a TV weather guy, reporter in a small town.
But But while I was doing that, I did a lot of comedy bits and things like that throughout my life.
Like, I remember when I was -- I was sort of the kid in high school that was always doing high school talent shows.
We had like a morning announcements, you know, TV news program, which was kind of like the local news for the high school that I was an anchor for.
And then, you know, I hosted like a local radio show for my local radio station.
And then even when I was in college, I was doing college TV, stand-up comedy and things like that.
And so I feel like I was getting the comedy reps in, but I thought at the time that that was me preparing myself to eventually, you know, report the weather in Post Falls, Idaho, or wherever my, you know, my career would have taken me, a real place that offered me a job shortly after I graduated.
And I remember when my professors kind of gave me the encouragement to actually pursue entertainment as a career.
It was right around when I was thinking -- when I was about to do a study abroad in London, and I at the last minute, switched my study abroad from CBS Radio News, the same place that Edward R. Murrow did his famous reporting in World War II, to an internship at a place called Baby Cow Productions, which created The Mighty Boosh, Gavin and Stacey, and a lot of other cool, like, alt-British comedy shows.
That was my first time really, I guess I would say, interacting with people who did comedy for a living, you know, behind the scenes, producers, writers.
And it really felt to me like, oh, these people feel like the people that I want to be like, you know, even from a demeanor standpoint.
You know, when I was in my 20s, you know, it was like, oh, when I'm 50, I want to be like these people.
And so I, you know, through alumni connections, got a job in Los Angeles assisting the guys that created Scare Tactics on Syfy.
And that gave me my first opportunities writing for, like, Tracy Morgan.
And, you know, just dove into the comedy scene and didn't really know exactly what I wanted my career to be as far as, like, you know, if I wanted to be a writer or director or an actor or anything like that.
But I just kind of kept hustling and kept doing the thing.
And through, you know, a lot of really kind friends supporting me, was able to kind of get jobs in the industry and just kind of work my way in.
But there's not really a direct path.
I kind of just worked hard and did things and was nice to people.
And then opportunities just over the years sort of presented themselves.
So I could ask you an academic question, but I really don't want to.
As somebody from the comedy world, and as a public-facing, you know, Native comedian, you know, with stand-up and all that, you know, heckling happens and sometimes in very targeted ways, let's say.
So my question is kind of what's the most fun you have had with a heckler in your career?
Oh, thanks so much for asking that question.
I thought that you were going to phrase that by saying the meanest heckle I've ever heard in my life.
I was like, oh, no, here we go.
So maybe you're really -- speaking of that, your outfit sucks.
Yeah.
Like, oh, I'm sorry.
Yeah.
So I'm, I'm primarily, I guess I would say, like an online comedian.
I don't really do like a lot of stand-up.
So my -- a lot of my heckling comes through like comments online.
And to me, like one of the funniest comments that I get is like, you know, I'm like a fairly lighter-skinned fella.
I'm maybe not necessarily what a lot of people would picture if they were to say, you know, draw a Native person.
I like to refer to myself as a reservation mullet, which to me means business in the front, powwow in the back.
And so I remember I got like a comment on one of my videos with somebody saying, there's no way that guy's Cherokee.
And I'm like, yeah, I'm Cowlitz, other side of the country, dude.
But that actually reminds me, you know, when you -- there was that one stat that 2/3 of Americans don't believe they've met a Native person.
That's kind of telling because I feel like a lot more have.
They just don't realize it.
Well, yeah, for sure.
I mean, I think that the way that I think about it is like there's, there's a really small box that society kind of like lets Native people fit in as far as appearances go while still claiming Native identity.
And that box is basically like, yeah, the crying Indian from those old PSAs who once again played by an Italian man.
So, but there's, there's Native folks of all shapes, sizes, and colors.
Like I'm, you know, a lighter-skinned Native person.
There's Afro-Indigenous folks who are Black and Native.
I actually have a chapter in my book called -- it's like color chart.
What skin tone is Native?
And it's like -- and it's just like, if you're white, you can be Native.
If you're Black, you can be Native.
If you're brown, you can be Native.
If you're yellow, you could be Native.
But also maybe you have jaundice, so go to a doctor.
If you're red, you can be Native.
You might have a sunburn.
Get some aloe on that, you know?
So yeah, it is important for me, I think, in the work that I do.
I always like give the note to animators and artists specifically in animation of like, you know, mix up the skin tones, make sure that it's like more representative and we're not just painting the picture of like one kind of image of how Native people look.
Yeah, it's the, it's the you don't look like one comment all the time.
And I always stare at them and be like, well, how many Natives do you actually know to like make that comparison of what we look like?
Well, yeah.
So, you know, you mentioned that statistic.
Like, I do think that I think there are a lot of people that have met and know Native people in their life that just don't know it.
And so, yeah, I think that a lot more people have met and hung out with Native folks and they know it's just they have not hung out with literally Pocahontas, so they're like, so they're like, are they?
You know, and they can read your book and then not embarrass themselves on accident.
Oh yeah, for sure, for sure.
Next question.
Okay, um, as a fellow -- you're also dressed fantastic.
Everybody in here is dressed great.
As a fellow writer, um, when it comes to creating ideas and creating things, um, how do you complete the project and then reach out to receive funding for the project?
Yeah, for sure.
So completing the project, I try to think about it as like it's important to win the day.
So that to me does not mean I'm going to sit down and write a whole book in an afternoon.
That sometimes the most writing that I do is I'll literally just create the file folder on my desktop that says book idea, and then that's all that I do that day.
But, you know, I think that creating and writing any big project, it's not one big step.
It's a series of very small steps.
So sometimes what I write is -- sometimes what I do is, I mentioned earlier, just creating the blank Google Doc that I'm going to start writing things in.
And then maybe the next day I'll write a sentence.
Maybe the next day I'll write a paragraph.
But if you do a little bit every day, at the end of it, you'll have a big finished product.
And as far as getting funding goes, there's not necessarily one exact way to do it.
So for me, I have the benefit of, you know, having a resume and a lot of things that I've done.
So it's, it's a little bit easier of a go for me.
Like, I got the funding for that short film Pow that we mentioned earlier.
That was off of -- in 2019, I won a comedy incubator lab called the Yes And Laughter Lab, which is a really great comedy lab that is basically for comedians that are creating projects that have some kind of narrative change component.
And it turns out that having comedy projects that just feature Native people in 2026 that are still alive counts as narrative change.
The bar is low.
So that one in 20 -- one of my projects won that in 2019.
That connected me with people who are connected with a lot of grant funders and organizations.
And fortunately, when like a few grants kind of passed one of their desks, they said, oh, Joey would be a great fit for this.
And then they offered to kind of walk me through that process.
So I fortunately have had a lot of people in my life who have helped kind of mentor me in that side of things.
I don't personally know how to do that process myself other than just people are nice to me.
But I will say, just like broadly speaking, I think it's important to start with projects that you think you can realistically do yourself.
That bear short that we mentioned earlier, that I self-produced, that I knew an animator in Los Angeles that I thought was really funny.
I knew a voice actor that was really good.
So that was a team of, you know, 3 or 4 people.
We recorded in my landlord's garage because he had a good mic setup.
And then I shared that, you know, in film festivals and it did really well and it did really well online.
So that was like a proof of concept that I could use to potentially get funding for like other things.
So like at the start, make things on your own that you think you could make.
Don't be afraid to do kind of crowdfunding if you can do like an Indiegogo or Kickstarter.
And then once you have your first success or 2, then you might find people who will just reach out to you kind of with opportunities, or it just kind of gives you a better ability to step into those rooms.
I hope that answers your question.
Apologies that my answer was not, oh, here's a checkbook, how much do you need?
But -- No, no, not at all.
Not at all.
It was just a curious question because, you know, you got -- you are in LA, right?
Yeah.
So it's a bigger market.
We're in Cleveland.
It's a smaller market, but it's actually a big market as far as film-wise because all of the major industry filmmakers come here to make their movies.
So, but it's harder for like smaller level writers to really get their ideas to the forefront without it being on YouTube or Tubi or, you know, you can't -- it's hard to get it on national television.
We had Superman, uh, filmed here.
Wow.
Yeah, that was really cool.
That's great.
Joey, how long did it take you to write the book?
Uh, so the book -- thanks so much for asking that question.
Um, oh, I would also say get involved in the Cleveland International Film Festival.
Like, they're really cool, and I think there's a lot of good connections there.
But yeah, it's just like surrounding yourself with people who are doing the thing for sure.
But yeah, honestly, the -- so the process of writing this book was very fast.
I wrote it in about a month and a half and a month and a half.
Yeah, a month.
The first draft in a month and a half.
Part of that's because I was on tour with my film Pow!
and I just -- there was a month and a half where it's like, okay, the book, if we want the book to come out in October of 2026, the first draft needs to be done on this date.
I have a month and a half where like I don't have to travel.
So I just had to like wake up every morning and just grind away at it, you know?
And fortunately, this book is basically like -- it's like a series of Onion articles.
So I don't have to like track a character arc or anything like that.
And that made it a little bit easier for sure.
But, you know, like I said earlier, it's just like starting, starting small and also like giving myself benchmarks of like, okay, every 10 days, if it's 4 sections, I need to have a section, at least the first draft of it written, and then just kind of back timing from there of how many pages you need to write.
But the book was so based on like a lifetime of experiences that me and my friends have had with sort of people not really knowing about Native issues.
So it's like in this situation, like I kind of went into it knowing what I wanted to say.
So in that case, it's just filling in jokes, for lack of a better term.
Nice.
Go ahead, Omar.
Greetings and salutations.
Thank you.
My query is this: in this era of media consolidation that we're seeing, that sometimes is crowding out more minority voices.
What space do you anticipate there being for these kind of Native-led projects moving forward?
Yeah, thank you so much for asking me a question that, if I answer it correctly, might cost me work.
Kidding, kidding.
It's fine.
But yeah, I think that You know, I will be honest with you in that, and not to get too political, but after the results of the 2024 election, there was, I think, a massive pushback against things like DEI, right?
And that extended to the entertainment industry.
You saw a lot of, you know, projects about and around marginalized communities, you know, getting either shelved or canceled.
And, you know, it was -- I think that Hollywood felt that there was like a national sentiment that was happening.
And, you know, with the recent results of the election 2 weeks ago or whatever, I think that Hollywood will take the lesson of like, oh, that's not what happened at all.
Maybe we should like rekindle those really dope POC projects.
And we are seeing, you know, I think that so much success specifically with Native stories, whenever Native stories are released, it's like they do great.
I mean, my book came out October 6th, and we sold out our first 2 printings on day one.
I was the number one bestselling nonfiction book in Oklahoma last week, and I think number 7 in SoCal.
There's the success of anything that Lily Gladstone touches.
I mean, North of North is one of the top shows on Netflix right now.
So I think that sometimes Hollywood is a complicated place where sometimes they will get stuck in a national conversation without looking at the numbers, but I think that with the politics of, you know, the sentiment of politics shifting, I think that it's going to cause, you know, the greater Hollywood industries to kind of reevaluate and be like, wait, whenever we release a Native project, it's like a smashing success.
Maybe we should do more of that.
So, you know, it is definitely something that is difficult to go through because there is also greater consolidation with, you know, studios being purchased by other studios and mergers and all that stuff.
But I am very optimistic because, I mean, whenever, whenever you give Native folks the opportunity to tell stories in mainstream spaces, it's like a roaring success.
And I think that ultimately the industry values money, and there's money in Native stories, you know.
Next question.
Um, if you could broadcast or display a message across every high school in America, what would you want to say?
And then also, if you could do the same thing, but for every news source in America, like targeting adults, what would you say, and would they be different?
Thank you.
Wow, that's such a deep question.
It's almost too deep.
Thanks for asking that.
Yeah, I selfishly wanted to say the answer to that would be buy my book.
But the real answer to that, and it's the same for both groups, is Native people are still here, and we rock.
So, and there are Native folks that are doing really fantastic things in this country, and it's really important to pay attention to and uplift voices that maybe previously have been censored.
So, you know, expand your horizons, look into histories that you haven't been taught, and pay attention to the things that schools aren't teaching you and try to learn about that stuff.
But yeah, thanks so much for that question.
Also, I should also say another thing I should say, I mentioned this in my book a lot, Maybe not for high school students, for adults.
You got to go to my tribe's casino in southern Washington State.
It's called Ailinay.
It's like a 20-minute drive north of Portland.
There's a hand drawing of my book of a map of how to get to my tribe's casino.
It's real fun.
It's called Ailinay.
It's in Ridgefield, Washington.
My tribe is going to ask why I've been slacking.
Like, I have not done a hand-drawn map at City Club forums of my tribe's casino.
So apparently I need to -- Yeah, you're like, you're -- I'm just like, not Not saying you're a bad Native, but like maybe your Chisito thinks otherwise.
Kidding, kidding, kidding.
Go ahead.
Sio, wado for this book and just everything in it.
One of the parts that popped out to me most was actually in the acknowledgments, and you talked about how Carissa walked you through how to handle the representation sweats.
And I was wondering if there was anything that you'd be comfortable sharing with, like, how you handle that.
Yeah, for sure.
Thanks so much for asking that question.
And so Spirit Rangers being, you know, such a historic show in Native representation, it was a blessing to work on.
But oftentimes when you're one of the first people to do something, there's like a pressure to represent everybody and there's a pressure to You know, want to make sure that we're representing our communities well, right?
Like one of my one of my one of the main goals of my career is just to not make the elders of my tribe mad at me.
You know, and for any Native folks in the audience, oh, you get it.
That's real.
And I think that it pressured me to really do my best to make sure that I was through my work and still am through my work.
Representing my tribe and then just Native people as a whole well.
I mean, I'm oftentimes the first Native person to ask to do a comedy show or take a meeting at a big production company or whatever.
And I make it a point to be prepared, show up early, don't be late, because I want to make sure that if I'm the first, that I'm allowing space for there to be a second, a third, a fourth, and et cetera.
So that's kind of where that pressure comes in for me.
And then Yeah, you know, there's just other stuff like making sure that I'm, you know, accurate and respectful with the representation that I do, making sure that like I have, you know, consult -- like I'm not an expert on, you know, my tribe's traditions, but I make it a point to work with elders who are to make sure that I'm, you know, getting feedback on the right things.
And, you know, I mean, there's a lot of projects that I work on where I'll like jump on the phone with a member of, you know, tribal council for my tribe and just make sure that I feel like I'm like threading the needle right.
But, you know, it is -- they call it the rep sweats because it's a lot of hard work.
And we often joked in the writers' room about like, I seriously doubt the SpongeBob SquarePants people are this stressed about, like, you know, about like getting Spud representation right on that show.
So, but, you know, I often think about, you know, specifically Spirit Rangers is like, that wasn't just a career highlight for me to work on that show.
It was a life highlight.
And to -- it's definitely a weight to carry, but to get to carry that weight was a blessing.
Great.
Next question.
Hello, and thank you so much for being here.
I just wanted to start that off.
My question is, did you always know that you wanted to make a living by supporting Native people through the entertainment field, or was there a specific moment in your life that helped you to make that decision?
Uh, yeah, thanks so much for asking that.
Um, it was definitely something that was a little bit of a slow journey, so, um, like, when I moved to Los Angeles, I just did it because I wanted to write jokes for a living and to work in comedy.
And a lot of my early comedy projects, you know, really tried to answer the important questions like, what if Spider-Man could rap?
Which the answer is, I don't know, it's fine.
It's kind of funny.
And eventually I started to realize like, wait, why am I writing jokes about Spider-Man or Lord of the Rings or whatever.
And at the same time, I also realized that I was one of only a few Native folks who were getting kind of mainstream opportunities in Los Angeles, in the greater LA comedy scene.
So I started to be a little bit more vocal about, you know, being an enrolled member of a tribe and, you know, making -- putting my Native identity a little bit more of the forefront in like my comedy bios.
And it just was so fulfilling and like wonderful to get to do that.
And then I started using my position also to uplift other Native comedians and give other Native comedians opportunities in mainstream spaces.
And, you know, started using comedy to tackle stuff I actually cared about, which is, you know, Native issues.
And, you know, at a certain point, I started to realize like, oh, this is so fulfilling and this is so fun.
And this feels like though I am hired to write, you know, non-Native characters and stuff like that, like whenever I get to tell Native stories, it feels like Oh, that's like why I'm here and why I'm doing it.
And that makes, you know, the representation sweats we talked about earlier just a little bit easier to carry because it's like, oh, this feels like my life's calling.
Great.
And I know there's so much more in the book.
You actually have a whole index in the back, not only of vocabulary and words that, you know, you might not know, but we may know, but also like other, you know, people to follow, books to read, documentaries to watch.
You have like 3, 4 pages just full of great recommendations.
Yeah, for sure.
It was, it was my goal in the book to really show people that, like, Native people are not a monolith.
I'm, I'm a dude who writes jokes for a living.
I'm not the expert, you know, be-all end-all on all things Indian Country.
So I really wanted to make the point in the book that, like, the way to get a full education about Native issues is to, like, try to seek out as many other Native perspectives as you can.
So, like, the last, like, 20 pages of the book are me offering my personal recommendations on, like, other Native filmmakers to follow, Native comedians, Native TV writers, Native authors, you know, books written by Native folks, Native organizations.
And I really wanted to give people as much of a jumping-off point as possible to show that this book is like hopefully the first step in your Native education journey, but not the last step.
Fantastic.
Friends, Joey Clift, thank you so much for joining us today.
His book, We've Been Here The Whole Time!, is out today.
Joey, a pleasure.
I'm so glad you're back here in Cleveland.
Let's do this again.
And thank you to our members and friends of the City Club.
I'm Cynthia Connolly, and this forum is now adjourned.
For information on upcoming speakers or for podcasts of the City Club, go to cityclub.org.
Production and distribution of City Club Forums by Ideastream Public Media are made possible by PNC and Nordson Corporation.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.
New Episode


New Episode

New Episode


New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
The City Club Forum is a local public television program presented by Ideastream