
Gov. DeWine considers removing people from death row | Reporters Roundtable
11/13/2026 | 54m 15sVideo has Closed Captions
Gov. Mike DeWine is considering whether to remove people from death row before his term ends.
Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine is considering commuting multiple death sentences before leaving office in January. The Ohio Parole Board will review cases from at least 10 counties. Ohio lawmakers also approved legislation changing how the state regulates firearm suppressors, short-barreled rifles and short-barreled shotguns. Senate Bill 214 would align state law with a recent federal policy change.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Sound of Ideas Reporters Roundtable is a local public television program presented by Ideastream

Gov. DeWine considers removing people from death row | Reporters Roundtable
11/13/2026 | 54m 15sVideo has Closed Captions
Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine is considering commuting multiple death sentences before leaving office in January. The Ohio Parole Board will review cases from at least 10 counties. Ohio lawmakers also approved legislation changing how the state regulates firearm suppressors, short-barreled rifles and short-barreled shotguns. Senate Bill 214 would align state law with a recent federal policy change.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Sound of Ideas Reporters Roundtable
Sound of Ideas Reporters Roundtable is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipWelcome to the Sound of Ideas Reporters' Roundtable from Ideastream Public Media.
I'm Mike McIntyre.
Good to have your undivided attention.
Who needs email anyway?
Governor Mike DeWine, who said this year that something many long suspected, that he opposes the death penalty, hasn't allowed an execution while he's been in office.
And now, as he prepares to leave, he's considering commutations for several death row inmates.
Prosecutors say they're troubled.
Measles continue to spread across the country and in Ohio, where more than 300 cases have been reported, many in Ashtabula, Geauga, and Wayne Counties.
Law enforcement agencies want the state to build guardrails around license plate reading cameras, but not scrap them because they're so valuable in fighting crime.
And photos generated with artificial intelligence had people afraid that lions had escaped from the Akron Zoo.
They hadn't.
Joining me at the table to discuss all of the news this week, from Ideastream Public Media, environment reporter Zaria Johnson, and from News 5 Cleveland, reporter Michelle Jarboe.
Hey, guys.
Good morning.
Good to be here.
Good to see you.
And this is not AI.
Ideastream's Statehouse News Bureau Chief Karen Kasler has escaped Columbus and joins us in the Smith Studio for today's show.
Hey, Karen.
Hey, it's great to be here.
Really good to have you here and welcome to the mothership.
All right.
Now, about that email thing.
Microsoft had us all rebooting our computers yesterday.
I know I was talking to a couple other people.
I kept hitting reboot and I'm like, what the heck is wrong?
And finally we found out for us around 1 o'clock.
But it felt, Karen, like we were back in the before times.
Yeah, I kept thinking, what am I missing?
What am I missing?
I know I've emailed people.
I'm sure they've emailed me.
What am I missing?
That's it just drove me crazy.
It was a worldwide outage and in fact continues now.
They say Microsoft says it's encouraging.
It has seen encouraging recovering process today.
My email started working about 7 o'clock.
You guys around the same?
Yep.
I think so.
Yeah.
My wife, on the other hand, was like, nope, still a spinning wheel.
I got nothing.
But it really reminds you of how much, at least for me, I depend on email, not only to receive information, but also to send information, even to communicate with people here and on my own staff.
It's, it's, it's essential now, sadly.
You think about that when things go down, how much you had relied on it.
Maybe we should figure out some workarounds.
We do have a workaround I'll tell you about later if you want to get in touch with the show and your email isn't working.
I'll tell you that in a minute.
But first, a note about another outage.
University Hospitals announced this week their systems, including the patient portal MyChart, back up and running finally after a 2-week outage due to what they termed a cyber threat.
No other details.
All right, on with the show.
If your email is working and you want to reach us, try soi@ideastream.org.
If email is a no-go for you, producer Aya Cathy will also monitor our direct messages this morning.
On Instagram and Facebook, we're @TheSoundOfIdeas.
Okay, let's get ready to roundtable.
Governor DeWine is considering commuting several death row sentences in his final days in office.
There have been no executions while he's been governor.
Karen, this is happening just before he ends his political career.
What has he said about the timeline on this?
Well, he said that this has been going on for the 8 years he's been in office, that he has been looking over death penalty cases, and indeed he has delayed executions for from the time that he took office in 2019.
Now, he's been saying that's because of a difficulty in accessing death penalty drugs, drugs for lethal injection.
But there's always been this question.
He's deeply Catholic.
There's always been this question about whether he had a personal opposition to the death penalty, which is interesting because he was the former prosecutor in Greene County and the former attorney general, both of whom are involved in death penalty cases.
But in June, he came out and said he wants lawmakers to abolish the death penalty entirely.
And now he says he's looking at some what he can do as governor on his way out the door to commute some sentences.
And we're hearing from the Prosecuting Attorneys Association in Ohio, they're troubled by that.
They want first of all, no one should be commuted, I suppose, is what their point of view is.
But also, we should be ramping up executions.
It's the law of the land.
Yeah, and that's been the question here.
I mean, I think DeWine at one point even said if lawmakers want to continue to use the death penalty, then they need to come up with a new protocol because Lethal injection, getting those drugs is not working.
And so there have been other ideas that have been proposed.
I believe one was nitrogen drugs, or nitrogen gas, I guess.
And none of those have gone anywhere.
But the prosecutors have always said that the death penalty is a tool they need to prosecute the worst of the worst cases.
And so they've always been concerned about the death penalty is imposed but then not actually carried out.
So prosecutors are concerned about this.
They want to know the process that DeWine going through once he decides who these people are that he's going to commute, if anybody.
But what I think is interesting, too, is the American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio says this is great.
Right.
Which is, you know, you don't often find Governor Mike DeWine on the side of the ACLU, except there are some certainly civil rights issues that he does agree with them on.
But they're happy about this.
And when the governor said that he was opposed to the death penalty, he did come out and say that earlier this year.
It wasn't, I'm doing that because I'm pro-life and Catholic.
He said it was because he didn't see it as a deterrent.
Right.
He said that there's no moral justification for it because it's not a deterrent.
So that's an interesting argument because it kind of crosses both ways, that is it a deterrent or not and is it a moral choice to make?
So he's we're watching this pretty carefully because we've long wondered if he was ever going to come out and directly say, I'm opposed to the death penalty, I want it to be abolished.
And he's done that.
Prosecutors in 10 counties, including 2 cases in Cuyahoga, have said that they've gotten notices that clemency hearings are coming.
But we're talking about maybe a little more than a dozen or some sort of small number.
It pales in comparison to Gavin Newsom in California, who also is leaving office.
He commuted the sentences of 548 people on death row.
So it's not of that kind of scale.
And the governor has said he's not doing a blanket commutation.
Right.
We only have about 100 people, I think, on death row.
And the, the whole process comes about because when former Governor Dick Celeste left office, he commuted the sentences of about 30 people, and that was considered problematic at the time.
So there's this process that's now in place and DeWine is looking over everything.
I don't know that we'll know anything before his last couple of days in office, though.
Okay.
More from the Statehouse.
The House and Senate passed a bill that removes short-barreled rifles and short-barreled shotguns, sawed-off shotguns, from a list of weapons that require registration and special licenses.
It also eases restrictions on firearm suppressors, silencers.
The bill now awaits Governor DeWine's signature.
Do we have an indication, first of all, whether he'll sign that?
I don't think we do.
This just passed this week because lawmakers are back for the first time since the election.
They've been gone for most they came back briefly in the summer to pass that fuel tax holiday.
But this is the first action that we've seen from them in several months.
DeWine signed other gun legislation.
So this, according to backers, really just puts Ohio in compliance with federal law because the Big Bill that was known as the One Big Beautiful Bill made some exemptions for these kinds of weapons, these short-barreled rifles and short-barreled shotguns, sawed-off shotguns, that it kind of took them into a different category.
This, according to the backers, just kind of brings Ohio into compliance with that.
But of course, there are some critics who are saying, hey, voters told us this month that they wanted us to come back here and start talking about affordability issues and start talking about property taxes and these kind of things.
Why are we doing this instead of doing that.
Yeah, those sawed-off weapons were on a list of dangerous ordnance, which includes torpedoes.
And so you're hearing folks say, listen, they're guns, let's regulate them like all other guns.
And yet there are those who were supporting this legislation early who changed their mind on that support because when it first started, it was really just about the suppressors, the silencers.
And the thinking was it's for hunters and not making a bunch of noise.
And so they could get behind that.
But then suddenly these things were added to it.
And we kind of see that occasionally.
At the Statehouse where something has passed through with either no no votes or almost unanimous support, and then something gets added in the process and it comes back to that chamber, and the people who voted for it are like, this is not the bill that I voted for the first time.
Because yeah, you're right, it was supposed to be a bill that just dealt with silencers, and then they added these other categories.
And so you had a lot of Democrats who said, hey, this is not what I want to see happen.
Representative Darnell Brewer says he's not anti-Second Amendment, he doesn't want to take people's guns, but he wants to promote responsible gun ownership.
There are a couple of bills that he said he was supporting that have had just a single hearing.
One of them was to exempt gun safety devices from sales tax and then offer a tax credit for handgun training.
Those don't seem to have moved anywhere.
And I don't expect that they will move in the very limited time that the legislature has to do what it's going to do before the end of the year.
So that's those aren't the only ones.
There are a couple other gun safety bills that are out there sponsored by Democrats, but those just don't tend to move in the current Republican supermajority.
That changes in January when it's still Republican dominated, but there's not a supermajority in the House.
Okay.
There have been more than 300 cases of measles in Ohio since January, and cases have been confirmed in 44 other states.
The U.S.
could lose its elimination status.
Zaria, first of all, where are we seeing most of these cases in Ohio?
So the highest numbers are in Ashtabula and Wayne Counties.
But this week, Geauga public health officials also announced cases or exposure at least in Geauga and Lake Counties.
There are a few different places, Berkshire Middle School and Kent's Geauga campus.
There was also a Berkshire Local School District fall concert, I think on November 3rd, where there could have been possible exposure.
So that's where we're seeing most of these cases and some more recent news of exposure that could lead to more cases in the future.
Yeah, I found that interesting.
I saw the press releases from public health agencies and they were listing like you know, this steakhouse and this place, like if you were at this place at this time, you might have been in contact with somebody who has measles.
Now, when we talk about elimination status, like measles was gone.
Right.
And now when we have a sustained over a year where you haven't stopped it, that's where you might lose the status.
There's been a hearing on that.
We don't know yet, but the US could lose that status.
Yeah, like you said, if you, if a country can't eliminate the disease within a year, then they are at risk of losing that status.
And we started seeing cases here in the US early last year.
So we've already, and I think Canada lost their elimination status already.
So it is on the table, but health officials are saying that the best way to protect yourself, the best way to avoid adding to these cases is to get that vaccine, the 2-dose of that vaccine that most people get as kids.
But if you're not sure about what your vaccination status is, then you can talk to your doctor about that directly.
All right, it's the Pan American Health Organization, which is a United Nations agency that issues that status.
So let's just talk about measles itself.
What do you do first of all if you believe that you have measles?
Yeah, so you want to call your doctor and they're asking you to call ahead instead of just walking into their office or an emergency room because the virus can stay in the air after 2, up to 2 hours after a person who is infected leaves.
So if you walk in, you could potentially be infecting the other people who are in that waiting room or whatever the case may be.
And at that point, you also want to keep an eye out on symptoms like a high fever, cough, runny nose, red and watery eyes, and a rash.
And it's important to note that it can lead to other long-term complications like pneumonia if these symptoms aren't addressed.
And if you are vaccinated, the measles, mumps, rubella vaccination, likely are protected?
Yeah, it's up to 97% effective according to health officials, and the CDC says that 96% of measles cases are people who are unvaccinated, so keep that in mind.
So we might just be seeing some fallout from the anti-vaccine discussion that's been happening and the tenor throughout the country.
Yeah, and previously it was mostly kids who were popping up with measles, but now it's people of all ages kids, adults, adolescents, all of it.
All right.
Ohio's leading law enforcement groups are asking state lawmakers to regulate Flock cameras and similar automated license plate readers They say they want stronger safeguards to prevent misuse of the data and protect residents' privacy.
So who are the groups and what action, Karen, are they asking lawmakers to take?
Well, this is interesting because it's some of the leading groups when it comes to law enforcement.
I mean, you've got the Prosecuting Attorneys Association, which we just talked about, but also the Buckeye State Sheriffs Association and some of the big police organizations.
They're all saying that Flock cameras and these automated license plate readers are invaluable tools.
They've solved crimes.
And so they're very concerned that communities, cities like Columbus where I am, have banned the use of Flock cameras over the concerns about abuse of the data that they collect.
And so these law enforcement groups are saying because these cameras are so important, we have to, as a state, put some limitations on them to make sure that the data isn't misused and the data is handled appropriately.
So this is something I do expect that maybe lawmakers might take some action on in lame duck because this has been an issue.
It showed up in the governor, the race for governor.
It showed up in a lot of different discussions because people feel like they're being surveilled, which they're not.
But there's an understanding that you could see why, because they are prevalent.
They're everywhere.
And different communities handle that data differently.
One of the things that we're looking at, and you already have that in some of the other databases that law enforcement can access, that they're not allowed to use them for personal find out where someone has been, check out, you know, run the license plate through the system.
The folks who are pushing for this, those organizations are saying there should also be penalties for people who misuse Flock data, that there actually is a penalty to you if you do that.
Yeah.
And I've heard everything from there are some groups that want to see any law enforcement officer who and that's really what it would be, is a law enforcement officer who'd be able to access this data.
For the most part, that that person should be charged with a penalty, never be able to work as a law enforcement officer again, that kind of stuff.
So I think that's a big part of this, that these law enforcement groups want to see people who abuse that data punished just like they are punished if they abuse the LEADS system, which law enforcement this is why I didn't say it.
I know, I know.
I said database.
Law enforcement automated data system.
There we go.
Got it.
Thank you.
So that's the system that allows When you get pulled over, they look you up, they look up your license plate and find out if you are wanted in another state or something.
Police officers get punished for misusing that.
Law enforcement gets punished for misusing that.
I think that there are law enforcement groups that want to see the same kind of punishment for officers who misuse data from Flock cameras.
Right.
If you run a license plate of somebody whose car was in your girlfriend's driveway, for example, or something of that nature, which we've heard before.
That's the surveillance and stalking thing that I think a lot of people are concerned about.
They feel like You know, I'm, I'm not doing anything wrong, but maybe somebody's gonna think I am, or they're gonna follow me around, they're gonna stalk me.
And I think that that's a, a real concern that people have.
So that's part of the reason why these groups wanna see some, some guardrails put on this.
And the law enforcement is saying this is an important tool.
I've heard this locally.
I was talking to a grand jury foreman locally who said, if we didn't have Flock cameras, half of these crimes wouldn't come to us.
So the police need them.
You're hearing the police agencies say this, but what the critics say is, show us the data.
Where do we know that Flock is helping?
And that's part of what these law enforcement groups want to see.
When I talked to Jay McDonald, who's with the Fraternal Order of Police of Ohio, he said that these kind of cameras are the most important technological advance in law enforcement in my entire career.
So that gives you an indication of how important lawmakers or law enforcement officers feel this is.
And so they're suggesting that these camera providers have some technological guardrails, but also that agencies put out how many, how many arrests have you made through Flock cameras?
How many charges did you file because of data from Flock cameras?
Because that would then allow these agencies to prove how important that they think these cameras are.
Flock in Cleveland as well is still making news.
Cleveland leaders are considering ending their contract with Flock Safety cameras, using another vendor, Axon, which already supplies the police departments with body cameras.
So what's the timeline for that decision, Michelle, with city council?
Sure.
So the existing Flock contract was renewed over the summer for 6 months.
So it ends around the turn of the year.
And on Monday of this week, the Bibb administration introduced legislation that would allow them to proceed with Axon entering potentially a 1-year contract with 4 1-year renewal options.
That legislation doesn't say specifically how many cameras would be installed or what the cost is.
And it's unclear how quickly the legislative process will move on that.
Because it really depends on members of council.
Right.
And there's currently, we have the Flock system.
As you said, it was a 6-month, it was supposed to be a year.
They cut it down to 6 months so they could do some looking into the contracts, et cetera.
About 100 cameras that are used in Cleveland.
What would Axon offer that's different?
Why is somehow just going to another vendor solving the problem that organizations like Flock know have protested?
Well, I think that that is what we will see get discussed at city council.
Apparently the city went through a process soliciting proposals, and they are suggesting they're making this recommendation based on a proposal they received in September from Axon.
We have not seen the details of that proposal yet.
One of the things that concerns that group, Flock No, is that the Axon company, unlike Flock, has federal contracts including with Homeland Security, Border Patrol, and Immigration Customs Enforcement.
They're worried that if those kind of linkages happen, and then there's also that Amy Acton used locally, we could be even in more of a Big Brother situation.
Yeah, I think it's fair to say, you know, expect a lot of scrutiny over this, expect a fight over it.
And to the points that you and Karen made, you know, there are folks in law enforcement who are advocating for keeping these tools in some form.
And then there are a lot of opponents who are concerned about surveillance and misuse of data and what other agencies have access to the data.
There were 40 suspected overdose deaths in Cuyahoga County in the last 5 weeks, bucking a downward trend according to the Cuyahoga County Medical examiner.
Cuyahoga has issued a public health alert as a result.
And it's so disappointing, Michelle, because we've been hearing Thomas Gilson, the medical examiner, say, wow, the numbers are getting and I remember having him on the show and he's like, alarm, alarm, alarm, like fentanyl and all of this.
And we're in big trouble.
And then suddenly things started to get better.
Now we have this period where we've spiked again.
He's concerned.
Yes.
And this is definitely noteworthy.
I think it is worth mentioning here that overall overdose deaths overdose deaths have been declining, and according to the medical examiner's office, they're down by roughly 50% from their peak in 2017.
But, but officials are very concerned about this recent spike.
And there's also been a shift in what the primary driver of these overdose deaths is.
So it has shifted from being fentanyl to cocaine, though in some of those cases with cocaine, fentanyl is also involved.
Hmm.
There's something called harm reduction we've discussed on this show in the past.
Some people are against it because they think it actually promotes drug use.
Others are saying this is happening and we need to reduce harm.
What does the medical examiner say about people developing a harm reduction plan?
They're encouraging people to develop a plan, and that would include keeping naloxone available, fentanyl test strips on hand.
You know, if somebody is going to use drugs, don't do it alone.
Sit up.
People should call 911 and seek treatment if they have any concerns.
And they've also been stressing, look, here are the symptoms of a cocaine overdose, including dizziness, shortness of breath, sweating, racing pulse, chest pain, seizures, and unresponsiveness.
And you're talking about it going from fentanyl to cocaine.
I was just hearing on NPR, I think yesterday, about how there are, because of the idea of taking drugs and changing molecules, that they're creating drugs that are 50 to 100 times more potent than fentanyl, that it's even getting worse.
And you would think people would say, oh, other people are dying from that, I should stay away from it.
Instead, they're saying, I can probably handle it, and it tells me that it's good and it's strong.
That's the battle that they're fighting.
Yeah, it seems like, you know, some people don't really know what they are taking.
All right, a couple of bits of feedback on what we've talked about from our listeners and viewers.
And by the way, you can reach us.
It looks like email is working.
soi@ideastream.org.
soi@ideastream.org.
Tom says, what's to stop Ring doorbell cameras from behaving in the same way as Flock cameras, sending video back to the parent company to be analyzed and tagged by AI and then aggregated into a database like flock to be used by police or the highest bidder?
It may have to be a rhetorical question for us.
I don't know if there's an answer, Karen.
I remember there was a Super Bowl ad a couple years ago that advertised that Ring cameras could be used to help find pets, missing pets, and it sounded like a great idea, but then people started thinking, hey, wait a minute, this is now you're talking about a network of kind of surveilling neighborhoods.
And so yeah, there's a real concern here, and I think that's That's another level of the feeling of being surveilled.
But people like their Ring cameras, I'll tell you that.
Yeah.
And I think, I think they actually are being used to find pets.
But I think it's somebody I think you have to opt in to the message because I get those messages all the time with a picture of a beautiful little doggy and, you know, somebody looking for them.
Another bit of feedback.
This is from Casey talking about Gavin Newsom's commutations.
He said when Newsom recently commuted the sentences of over 500 people on death row.
He said that by doing so, he may have saved the lives of 30 innocent people.
He's drawing on research by experts on our penal system who claim that anywhere from 2 to 10% of people presently incarcerated in this country are likely innocent.
The justice system is not nearly as faultless as most citizens want us to believe.
And that's one thing that's come out of kind of the study of the death penalty in Ohio, is there's a report that was done for the Ohio Supreme Court all sorts of recommendations on the death penalty in Ohio.
And there is a real question about the judicial process and how certain counties prosecute and the death penalty is delivered more often than in other counties.
So there's a real question about whether it's really uniformly applied and whether there are racial issues, there are economic issues involved.
So there's a lot here.
All right.
Almost a full day off of email makes people really want to send emails.
We've got another one.
This one from Stephen.
Said having the kind of high-level widespread surveillance that the systems like Flock provide has a chilling effect on all behavior, whether it's legal or not.
Also, relying on those systems for policing can have an atrophy effect on the other policing skills so that when the system fails, police will be at an even bigger disadvantage.
We all got that when our email failed, but his point being, if you start relying on Flock and then somehow that system is down, we've relied on it so hard, how do we do policing again?
Yep.
All right, great point, Stephen.
Appreciate that.
And we'd like your feedback, soi@ideastream.org.
And we've got plenty more to talk about, including more live music venues coming to Cleveland just as the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is about to open its expansion, and trouble at Ohio State University after 2 students were burned during a frat party.
First, here's Sound of Ideas host Stephanie Haney with a preview that will bring you next week on The Sound of Ideas on 89.7 WKSU.
Hey there, Mike.
Here's what we have coming up next week on The Sound of Ideas.
We're starting things on Monday with our Law of the Land series, where we look at how the law affects our everyday lives.
We're looking at the issue of medical aid in dying, which is currently illegal in Ohio, but there are people who are pushing to get it legalized.
We'll talk with 2 proponents, both Ohio women.
One woman whose stepfather Jack was able to take advantage of a medical aid in dying law on the West Coast, and another woman whose husband David, while living here in Ohio, tried to take advantage of a law on the East Coast but was not able to do that before he passed away.
We'll also be talking with Shaker Heights native David Pogue, who you may recognize from CBS Sunday Mornings.
He'll be in town talking to students at CSU Law about artificial intelligence in the legal field, looking at everything from how it's impacting evidence in the courtroom to workflow for attorneys.
On Wednesday, we talk with another Northeast Ohio native, actor and comedian Yvette Nicole Nicole Brown.
She stopped by the Idea Center to talk with us about the role she is voicing in the animated Disney movie Hexed, which is coming out just before Thanksgiving.
We also talked with her about being from East Cleveland and her advice for people from our area who have big aspirations.
On Wednesday and Thursday, we're bringing you segments that are produced in partnership with students from Cleveland State University.
On Wednesday, we'll be talking about third spaces and the lack of third spaces for young people in all also the rise in teen takeovers of areas around Northeast Ohio.
On Thursday, with another class, we'll be talking about the rise in independent publishers.
Also on Thursday, Mark Puente from the Cleveland Marshall Project will join us.
He'll share his reporting, which is a follow-up piece from him on racial bias in speeding citations in the Bratton Hall area.
And we'll round things out on Thursday with Shuffle, our music podcast.
Back to you in the studio, Mike.
Thank you, Steph.
You're back with the Sound of Ideas Reporters' Roundtable from Ideastream Public Media.
I'm Ideastream's editor-in-chief, Mike McIntyre.
I'm joined today by Ideastream's Zaria Johnson, News 5 Cleveland's Michelle Jarboe, and our Statehouse News Bureau chief, Karen Kasler, right here in the Smith Studio with us.
Did you take the news quiz yet?
You should.
It's fun.
Find it on our website, ideastream.org/quiz.
All right.
We talked about many major topics.
We always hit It seems, Flock cameras every week now.
It comes up and we always talk about data centers.
And now we're going to do that.
Ohio voters in 21 communities approved restrictions or bans on data centers in last week's midterm election, reflecting widespread concerns that we've been hearing over the last year.
A new report from the Ohio Chamber of Commerce, though, offers a counterargument that data centers bring billions of dollars and thousands of jobs to the state.
So, Karen, tell us about the recent report.
What its findings are and what it is attempting to do.
Well, one quick thing.
It was 21 ballot issues in 18 communities.
There was one community, Wilmington, in southwest Ohio, that had 4 issues related to data centers.
And they were all overachievers.
Right.
They were all related to bans and restrictions on them.
And they all passed.
In fact, I think nationwide there were 41 such issues and all but one went against the data centers.
So the Ohio Chamber of Commerce has been a supporter of data centers in general.
They've done a couple of reports through their chamber foundation that say data centers are economic generators.
This last one says that they generate $9 billion in revenue coming back to the state and almost 70,000 jobs, almost 14,000 direct jobs making around $148,000 a year when you talk about pay and benefits.
So the report was really praising what data centers have done.
But there's been this admission that data centers have not done a very good job of convincing voters, convincing residents that they are a good thing.
And so there's a lot of skepticism when you look at this report now.
And for our TV show, the State of Ohio, this week, I talked to one of the backers of the amendment that would ban large data centers.
They're still gathering signatures.
And he said, you know, he's not seeing the wealth that this report talks about.
He's not seeing that in his community, that maybe it is, maybe data centers are creating that kind of revenue.
He's not seeing it out his window.
And what I'm hearing from people is, yeah, maybe it's creating tax revenue, but it's also taxing our water system.
It's also taxing our electrical grid.
And it's also this massive thing that's in a place that I bought property in because it was rural and bucolic.
Well, and some of these data centers are still under tax abatements and still under tax agreements that basically there's no sales tax on them.
And that's important because they still have to even after they're constructed, they still have to buy equipment and chips and that sort of thing.
So we're talking about lots of money in sales tax that could be coming that's just not.
Also property taxes.
Some communities aren't getting property taxes from the data centers there.
So schools aren't benefiting and local services like police and fire aren't benefiting.
So there has been this real push and pull that we've seen fairly quickly coming forward.
I mean, this whole thing with data centers happened really fast.
Yeah, just a couple of years ago, data centers were, hey, it's clean industry.
This is great.
And now people are starting to raise concerns, like you said, about the water, about these huge facilities on land that used to be open.
A lot of these people are living in communities where they like that open space.
And now there's a data center there.
There's noise issues.
There's just all sorts of concerns that people have about them.
And not to mention the lack of transparency.
They feel like these things were thrown into their communities without anybody even telling them, hey, this is Big things coming.
Had Vivek Ramaswamy won the governorship and been the governor-elect now, you might assume that he would be in league with the Chamber of Commerce on this.
Where does Amy Acton stand now that she is the governor-elect?
Well, both Acton and Ramaswamy had issued conditional data center moratoriums, and he had said several times that he would issue this by this data center moratorium by executive order on day one.
But we don't talk about that now because Amy Acton is the governor-elect and she's talked about actually her data center moratorium came out first.
She wants specific conditions like that they have to pay for their own energy, that they have to be constructed with 100% union labor, which a governor can't order that.
But she says that she would use her position to advocate for that.
So it remains to be seen what she's able to do.
But one of the things when you start talking about data centers providing their own energy, that means you're talking about data centers potentially building natural gas plants and potentially building small nuclear plants in those communities.
And so that's another thing that people are starting to come across and feel like, hey, this is really not what I asked for and I'm very concerned.
All right.
Locally, Cuyahoga Falls is among those communities unconvinced about the benefits of data centers.
City Council there just passed new standards to prohibit the construction of large scale data centers.
So this isn't something went to the ballot box for, but it's something that the City Council did.
Zaria?
Yeah.
And it passed with a 10-to-1 vote in favor.
And I talked to Mayor Don Walters who said that these restrictions are basically put in place to find a balance between industry, the potential economic benefit, and community, community resources, water, electricity rates, things like that.
So these data centers can only be placed, built, located in areas zoned as employment or manufacturing districts.
So places that aren't going to be right next to a residential neighborhood.
They can't exceed 5,000 square feet in size.
And there can only be one actual data center building on the property.
And since Cuyahoga Falls owns its own water and electric utilities, they were in a unique position where they could restrict the amount of electricity that could be used by the data center and the amount of water that could be used as well.
And you said 5,000 square feet.
So, I mean, that's tiny compared to some of these hyperscale things that we've been seeing.
Yeah.
And that's what this restriction is on those large-scale data centers.
He said that they already have a few small data centers in Cuyahoga Falls.
We have small ones here in Cleveland.
He said that he doesn't want to, and council didn't want to prevent these small data centers from being built here if they need them, or from small data centers adding or expanding by adding another data center elsewhere in the city.
But they just want to protect the community from those hyperscalers that people are worried about everywhere else.
Yeah, and we're hearing the council president there saying basically that we're trying to strike a balance.
Exactly.
It sounds to me like this is what we're going to see either at the ballot box or in council chambers across the country.
Yeah, and that the mayor had the same perspective of finding that balance.
And he said that they could have considered an outright ban on data centers, but he felt that that was a bit too restrictive and potentially could have blocked the city from any, any positive industry wanting to come in if they needed a data center.
So they're trying to walk that fine line.
The mayor said they want the best of both worlds in that regard.
Karen, I just wanted to add, in my conversations with the group Conserve Ohio, which is the one that's backing this constitutional amendment, they have about 150,000 signatures that they've gotten.
They need a lot more than that.
They need about 400,000.
Now that we've had a new governor's race, they're going to need probably about 450,000 valid signatures, meaning they're going to have to collect like 6,000 600,000 signatures.
So they're a long way from getting that amendment, which would ban not what Zaria is talking about, but the large, the really big, massive ones.
And they're in discussions, I guess, hoping that what Amy Acton does will maybe make a difference here.
We'll just have to see.
Ohio State's Sigma Alpha Epsilon fraternity has been suspended after a party in which at least 2 people were set on fire.
The university said the individuals in question were receiving needed medical care.
Let's talk about this, Zaria.
And we've heard of hazing.
We don't know yet that this is a hazing event, but we've heard about this happening on college campuses.
What's the story here?
What do we know?
Yeah, this is still being investigated by the Columbus Fire Department.
They're working with the Ohio State Police.
And it's interesting because the police and fire say they didn't get any calls about this incident.
When it happened on Saturday.
But there was video.
But there was a video, and once the video circulated Sunday morning, that's when the calls started coming in.
So it's still under investigation about what actually happened, how the fraternity might be involved.
So right now they're placed on temporary suspension while the investigation is underway, which means that the fraternity can't show up to any university events as a registered university organization.
This particular fraternity has a history of suspensions there.
There's been other problems.
Yeah, um, for more than a decade, the Sigma Alpha Epsilon chapters have been banned or suspended at several universities.
That includes Michigan State, where they were suspended for alleged drug use.
Karen, you've got a son at Ohio State.
I always expect that you get the student perspective on this.
Yeah, I that when you show that picture of SAE, I've seen that many times as I drive past his fraternity.
He doesn't live at the house, but he's in a fraternity.
And this is, this is serious.
And this made the rounds for students very, very quickly.
And what is also serious, not only was this at a party, but this could potentially have been some sort of a pledge activity, some sort of a hazing activity.
If it is, that's seriously concerning because there are laws that protect pledges.
There are laws that protect people in those kind of circumstances.
So that'll be another level that Ohio State is going to have to deal with.
And then police could potentially be brought in, prosecutors could be brought in.
But when a fraternity is under suspension, they can't they can't do any sort of activities.
They can't have any sort of pledge activity.
So we're in rush right now.
And, well, we are, but the kids are.
Right.
And, you know, that really does shut down what happens at the fraternity, which is a good thing when you start looking at this.
So it's SAE is the largest fraternity in the country, I believe.
And so this is the kind of thing, though, that just any parent who looks at this is just horrified, not to mention anybody in general, but a parent who's thinking about sending their kid to college or their kids in college.
You don't you never want to see that.
I mean, it's horrible.
And did you see the video?
Did anyone see this?
I did.
You did.
And so my son sent it to me.
So the other part is just what's It wasn't like this big emergency situation in the video, right?
It looked treated kind of cavalierly.
Yeah.
I mean, obviously those, those 2 guys were severely hurt, second, third-degree burns.
So it was serious.
But when these things happen, a lot of times they get really out of control.
That's part of why there are laws now about hazing.
So.
Right.
In related news, OSU buildings named after billionaire and university mega donor Les Wexner will not be renamed anytime soon despite increased scrutiny surrounding Wexner's relationship with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.
So there had been a push, there was supposed to be a review, and they were going to look at it, and suddenly that's now gone.
What happened?
There were more than 500 requests sent in for review, but interim Provost Trevor Brown decided to stop the review of those requests.
And this is university policy.
The provost is required to decide whether or not the renaming committee moves forward with that review, and after the review, the decision would be then presented to the President.
So this isn't necessarily unique.
However, there have been questions raised about conflict of interest because Interim Provost Brown previously served under Wexner on the board for the Wexner Center for the Arts Foundation.
So it's unclear if the University then has a policy or procedure on removing a Provost from that responsibility if there is a conflict of interest.
present, right?
Uh, Karen, where does the university stand in its relationship with Wexner?
Uh, well, I think he was, uh, one of the university trustees.
University trustees.
Um, he's no longer a trustee, I believe.
But I mean, if you haven't been to Ohio State, the, the, the name Wexner is everywhere.
Yeah.
And so, I mean, the, the medical center is huge and it's everywhere.
The Wexner Center for the Arts, which is internationally known Right on High Street, right in the middle of campus.
I mean, his name is everywhere.
So to take his name down is a huge responsibility, a huge task.
But obviously there are a lot of people who are really concerned about that name being associated with Ohio State and want to see it gone.
Ceremonial shovels broke ground this week on a new outdoor music venue in downtown Cleveland slated to open in 2028.
The amphitheater is part of a larger effort to redevelop 35 acres along the Cuyahoga River.
Michelle, let's talk about who's behind the project.
This is Bedrock?
Yes, that's right.
So Bedrock is the Detroit-based real estate arm of Cavs owner Dan Gilbert's Rock family of companies.
This also involves Rock Entertainment Group, which is another one of the family of companies.
They operate Rocket Arena and then Live Nation.
And so they're partnering on the project.
Live Nation will operate the venue with a capacity of about 6,200 people, and they're expecting that the venue will host both national touring acts and local performers.
So it seems to me we already have an amphitheater on the Cuyahoga River.
It's called Nautica, and it's across the way, right?
We, we do.
Yeah, Jacobs Pavilion there is not Nautica anymore.
How old am I?
I mean, the name has changed a few times over the years, but yeah.
So we have that.
It's right across the river.
And I was talking to people the other day, like, what if there are 2 concerts concerts at the same time?
Are they going to be competing and there's going to be a big sonic boom?
Well, I mean, I mean, they're not right next to each other, but certainly, you know, a couple curves of the river apart.
And I mean, folks I've talked to, you know, smaller venue operators in the music business say this is definitely a battle of the big guys that's going on, that, you know, Bedrock's amphitheater is going to be squaring off against the existing venue up the river.
And it's worth noting Live Nation used to operate Jacobs Pavilion.
They do not anymore.
It's operated by AEG, a competitor.
So, so, you know, you talk to like Cindy Barber over at the Beachland Ballroom on Waterloo.
She, characterizes this as a competition, just more of the competition between the big guys.
Battle of the titans.
Yeah.
And we have the Odeon coming back to life.
A company has purchased that.
That's a historic venue in the Flats.
Seems like more and more places to watch live music.
Good reason.
It's the rock and roll capital of the world.
We're about to have an expansion of the Rock Hall.
But you also just wonder, is there enough capacity for that?
Is there enough live music capacity for that and all of these independent venues?
And then the big ones like going out to Blossom or going into the Rocket Arena for, you know, the Springsteens.
Yeah.
And, you know, proponents of all of this will say, look, there are a lot of venues of different sizes and different locations that are suited to serving different kinds of acts.
But the independents are particularly concerned about getting lost in the shuffle.
Folks with these smaller venues who have recovered to a degree from COVID but live music attendance isn't necessarily what it was, particularly at those smaller to mid-sized venues.
All right, Zaria, who do you want to see first at the new venue in 2018?
You know the answer.
Okay, Beyoncé.
Beyoncé.
That would be a very small Beyoncé show.
Just me and Beyoncé, it's even better.
I acted like a lawyer there.
You never ask a question you don't know the answer to.
And that's exactly do you guys h Do you who would you want to see first at this concert venue?
No, nothing.
Oh, I don't know.
You know, during COVID Nine Inch Nails and the Pixies were supposed to come to Jacobs Pavilion, and then that got canceled.
And that'd be cool.
I mean, I, I know Nine Inch Nails, when they finally came through, went to Rocket Arena, but it would be great to see them down there on the river.
Yeah, let's get them in a smaller venue.
Karen, the last concert I tried to buy tickets for sold out like immediately.
So I'm obviously in the larger arena category.
So maybe we can shrink them down and get them to a nice little thing.
Let's go for the intimate experience.
Exactly.
You weren't going to say Taylor Swift?
I'd go for the Avett Brothers for sure.
And I saw them at I think it's called Nautica, but maybe it's the Smithsonian, but maybe there.
All right.
Westlake City Council has voted to restrict E-bikes to roadways, not sidewalks.
Riders under 18 must wear a helmet.
And unless you're at least 14, you can't ride E-bikes anywhere in Westlake.
So tell us more about these rules.
I laid out most of them, but yeah.
There's a lot of worry about E-bikes across the nation.
Oh yeah.
And Westlake's taking some action.
And the speed is something that I've been hearing a lot about, especially when E-bikes are potentially going to be on the road.
And so in Westlake, E-bikes can't go any faster than 28 miles per hour, and you can't have more than one rider on an E-bike at a time.
You mentioned they can't be used on sidewalks, shared-use paths, trails, bike paths, or walkways.
They have to be on the road.
And there's no differentiation between the Class 1, 2, or 3 E-bikes.
Class 3 E-bikes, the maximum speed is 28 miles per hour.
So if you're in Westlake shopping for a bike, Class 3 is where you want to be.
Class 3 or lower, and you'll be good to go.
Right.
And there aren't those kinds of class there are those kind of class differentiations in other places like Bay Village.
The other things are about helmet use.
Yeah.
So riders need front lights and rear reflectors when they're biking at night.
Night time.
And if you don't have that, then it could lead to a minor misdemeanor citation.
Repeat offenses could, within a year, could be a 4th-degree misdemeanor.
And the city will, or is at least planning to, remind drivers to give that 3-foot clearance to cyclists as well.
And in terms of helmets, I think those under 18 need to wear a helmet, required on those vehicles.
But also, I saw the other day in Westlake Somebody on a scooter that was one of those electric scooters that was flying.
So I wonder whether this and maybe we need to look into it whether this E-bike regulation also applies to any E-vehicle.
Yeah, that's a that's something I think we maybe should look into because in my opinion, the E-scooters are scarier.
I've heard horror stories about people riding scooters and falling off and hurting themselves.
So I can only imagine if that's in the street what that could do.
So that's a good point, Mike.
We'll have to look into that.
Take a look at that.
Another thing that could happen in lame duck is there is legislation that would set some kind of statewide standards on both E-bikes and E-scooters because of exactly what we're talking about here.
And there's this kind of patchwork in different communities.
So if you move from one to the other or you're visiting somebody from one to the other, you don't know what the rules are necessarily.
I like how they call it lame duck, but all kinds of stuff usually gets done during lame duck.
It's like the most active time.
Yes.
Well, and we, we have this year over 1,000 bills in the House and about 475 bills in the Senate.
That's a lot.
So there's a lot of ideas to pick from if they want to go ahead and put some things together.
I expect one big bill that gets a lot of stuff in there.
That's the Christmas tree bill.
The Christmas tree bill.
Have you read all of these bills, by the way?
No.
Halfway through?
Yeah.
1,000, 1,500 bills?
No.
Okay.
Fair.
Community groups working in violence prevention, restorative justice, or mediation can now apply for grant funding from the Cleveland Community Police Commission.
However, there are concerns about the grant allocation process.
Some previously awarded organizations are still awaiting their funding.
So what's going on with these grants, Michelle?
Yeah, so, so they, they have moved forward slowly.
Just a little bit of background here.
So the city charter says that the commission is entitled to 0.5% of the amount budgeted for the Cleveland Division of Police to fund the grants.
According to reporting by Signal Cleveland, that came to almost $1.4 million.
This year, but the commission has said, you know, it struggled to move the process along largely due to staffing issues.
So now, now they feel that they have the staff in place to try to move things forward, but they're playing catch-up while opening a window for new grant applicants.
And what can the money be used for?
Yeah, so as you alluded to, you know, violence prevention programs, restorative justice programs, and mediation programs, up to 15 grants can go toward relatively small organizations, so groups with an annual budget of under $1 million and a record of neighborhood service and limited foundation or government support.
Another 5 grants could go to groups serving specific populations in the city.
So you're talking about immigrants and refugees, the LGBTQ+ community, and people affected by police or gun violence.
All right, talking about the impact of violence, a new memorial in Cleveland's Collinwood neighborhood honors more than 2,300 young people killed by homicide in Cuyahoga County over the past several decades.
And we're seeing some video of that on the television show as well.
It's really impressive.
Zaria, what's the story behind the Wall of Sorrows?
Yeah, it was created by Judy Martin.
She's a local advocate and head of survivors and victims of tragedy.
She partnered with a nonprofit called Black on Black Crime to bring the display together, and it features the names of more than 2,300 victims under the age of 25 who victims of homicide and She started tracking the names after her son Christopher was killed during an attempted carjacking in 1994, and she wanted to bring about a new memorial after a previous version in East Cleveland was torn down about 10 years ago.
So these 2 organizations partnered to bring this memorial together.
Great.
Cleveland would like to move its EMS headquarters.
They want to move them emergency medical services and some fire department officials into a shuttered public school building, but city council tabled the proposal and has questions.
So why is the move being considered now?
Yeah, so, so the school district closed 18 of its own buildings at the end of the last school year.
They also dropped a handful of leases.
So there are these buildings out there looking for new uses.
The city meanwhile has is going through the process of a widespread overhaul of its public safety footprint.
So some of these former school buildings have been earmarked for other public uses, including city uses.
And there's just some question about, from City Council, some concerns they have about moving the headquarters away from downtown.
You'd be 21 minutes away.
I don't think it necessarily means all the ambulances are in that spot.
No, no.
It's the administrative part.
But still, there's some discussion.
Council tabled it for that reason.
Yeah, that's right.
So they just held the legislation in the Safety Committee.
So expect it to come back up.
And I should say that the school board actually has already approved legislation related to this, or, you know, they've approved I shouldn't use the word legislation.
On their end.
Yes, they have approved their version of this deal, so they're waiting on City Council.
But yeah, the idea here is this would be a consolidated public safety administration complex.
It would be in the former Miles School, which is on the city's southeast side, so like at Miles Avenue and East 119th Street.
And council has had a lot of questions about this, just like they've had a lot of questions about the repurposing of any of these former Cleveland school buildings.
Meanwhile, there were some public safety officials at the safety committee meeting who were saying, look, we need new facilities.
This is a solution.
It's a relatively low-cost solution.
And we're dealing with overcrowding, broken equipment, and in one case, quote, deplorable conditions at our facilities.
They need something to go into these schools.
The longer they're empty, the worse things become.
So if you've got a city agency that go in, you can see where the school said, great, let's do this deal.
Sure, and city agencies that are saying, look, our current facilities are just a mess and we need to relocate.
I should say this also would be a sale-leaseback deal with the city.
So the city would buy the building but lease part of it back to the school district, which would be used for a career training program focused on public safety.
Boys and Girls Clubs of Northeast Ohio will close 5 locations next month, affecting about 300 children and families who rely on the programs.
For after-school care.
The organization says the closures are due to a projected budget shortfall in 2027.
This is just breaking news, Zaria.
Which locations are closing?
When will they shut down?
And boy, that's going to have an impact.
Yeah, so there are 5 locations that are scheduled to close on December 18th.
3 are in Lorain County and 2 are in Cuyahoga County.
Westwood Schools in Elyria and Wellington, Lorain High School, and locations in Norwalk and Ashtabula.
Like you said, it'll affect between 250 to 300 children.
And what's behind the funding shortfall?
Yeah, so, the CEO Allen Smith said, uh, the organization used its operating budget and state funding to keep the clubs open after the pandemic relief money and other grants expired, um, but it can't afford to cover those costs anymore at this point.
Karen?
I've been the emcee for the Boys and Girls Clubs of Ohio, the Youth of the Year Award, the last couple years.
I think the last 6 years.
These what these clubs do for these kids is just amazing.
I mean, these kids come out of those clubs so just prepared for everything.
And it's just I hate to hear this because these clubs have done so much great work and these kids really, really benefit.
Any chances, Zaria, that these locations, once closed, could possibly reopen?
Yeah, Smith said the sites could reopen if the funding becomes available again, but keeping one location operating through the rest of the year would cost about $100,000.
So they really just need a reliable source of funding to figure out if they can cover the cost and keep some or reopen some of these buildings after the closures.
Okay.
Akron-based Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company fired its CEO and a board member will slide in while a search for a successor ensues.
Michelle, Mark Stewart led the company since 2024.
Board has faced some financial challenges over the years.
So let's just talk briefly about that, about this issue?
Sure, yeah, so clearly, you know, the board felt that it was time for a change and that the CEO had not been able to fix things quickly enough.
You know, Goodyear is dealing with a lot of headwinds, you know, competition, inconsistent customer demand in cases where some customers are shifting to cheaper tires, and there's been a special board committee that throughout this year has been working on a strategic review of the business, business.
And clearly they've come to a decision point that they need new leadership and they need to be telling the market they're doing more.
We've seen a lot of trouble with tire companies.
We've seen Akron, the fallout from that.
Let's hope that this is something that keeps Goodyear strong for Akron.
All right.
A post circulating on Facebook claimed 2 African lions from the Akron Zoo escaped earlier this week.
The photo showing them off zoo grounds turned out to be made with artificial intelligence.
Zaria, though, the post went viral and we're seeing it, that one of them's carrying a traffic barrel and the other one's, you know, lying by the side of the road.
This is crazy.
You could easily see why you'd believe it.
Yeah, it's honestly scary seeing how advanced AI has gotten.
I remember seeing that first AI video of Will Smith eating spaghetti a couple years ago and it looked ridiculous.
And now we have this AI lion escape at the zoo freaking a bunch of people out.
So it's definitely concerning.
Um, the, the Akron Zoo did, uh, lead a safety drill, an animal escape safety drill that they have to do anyway to keep their accreditation by the Association of Zoos and Aquariums.
So they're prepared if this actually does happen, but this was not the case.
It was AI.
Don't trust it.
Okay, so we are that's a public service.
The lions are in there.
They're safe.
They're fine.
They're in their cages.
You really should check anything out that you see on the internet that looks a little bit spooky.
All right, some traffic news you need to know.
Starting at 9 tonight, Friday night, November 13th, I-90 will be fully closed in both directions between Central Avenue and just east of Carnegie Avenue as the project to demolish the East 22nd Street and Cedar Avenue bridges that run over the interstate begins.
I-77 north to 90 east will be closed too.
Highway is set to reopen Saturday at 5, and then we do it all again the next week.
So just make sure you're aware of that if you're driving tonight, Friday night, through tomorrow, through the day on Saturday.
And that's all for today.
My thanks to you, Zaria, Michelle, and Karen.
Great to have you here at the Idea Center.
It's great to be here with everybody.
Good to have all of you.
All right.
If you missed any part of the show today, you can hear a rebroadcast tonight at 9 on 89.7 WKSU.
Check out the Sound of Ideas podcast where you get your podcasts or head over to Ideastream Public Media's YouTube page.
To get the last word on today's topic, send an email, soi@ideastream.org.
And Monday on The Sound of Ideas, our host and resident bar-certified lawyer Stephanie Haney leads a discussion about medical aid in dying in our latest installment of Law of the Land.
I'm Mike McIntyre.
Thanks for being with us.
And stay safe.
And to close out today, where the Lions Are by Canadian folk artist Bruce Cockburn.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.
New Episode


New Episode

New Episode


New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
Sound of Ideas Reporters Roundtable is a local public television program presented by Ideastream