
At a Crossroads: The Future of LGBTQ Rights, Policy, and Public Life in America
Season 31 Episode 46 | 56m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
At a Crossroads: The Future of LGBTQ Rights, Policy, and Public Life in America
Over the last several years, the legal and political landscape for the LGBTQ community has evolved, placing long-standing civil rights at the center of major policy changes across the nation. Whether in the workplace, schools, or public spaces, the country has entered a new era in the fight for LGBTQ equality.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
The City Club Forum is a local public television program presented by Ideastream

At a Crossroads: The Future of LGBTQ Rights, Policy, and Public Life in America
Season 31 Episode 46 | 56m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Over the last several years, the legal and political landscape for the LGBTQ community has evolved, placing long-standing civil rights at the center of major policy changes across the nation. Whether in the workplace, schools, or public spaces, the country has entered a new era in the fight for LGBTQ equality.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch The City Club Forum
The City Club Forum is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipProduction and distribution of City Club Forums by Ideastream Public Media are made possible by PNC and Nordson Corporation.
Good afternoon and welcome to the City Club of Cleveland, where we are devoted to conversations of consequence that help democracy, democracy thrive.
It's Thursday, November 5th.
Remember, remember the 5th of November.
And I am Amanda Cole.
My pronouns are she/her.
I serve as the executive director of Plexus, the LGBT and Allied Chamber of Commerce of Northeast Ohio.
On behalf of Plexus, we are pleased to partner with the City Club on this afternoon's forum with Imani Rupert-Gordon, President of the National Center for LGBTQ Rights.
And there, I do need to reflect, last time I was in this space was in January at a forum, and I left that forum unsure of how to walk back into this space.
And I'm not sure -- or I'm sure I'm not the only one.
But today, I and Plexus take the step towards repair and doing the gritty, complicated work of democracy, to show up and have conversations of consequence, and to be brave and vulnerable in that.
Over the last several years, the legal and political landscape for LGBTQ community has greatly evolved.
Longstanding civil rights have been at the center of many major policy changes and arguments, whether in the workplace, schools, public spaces.
This country has entered a new era in the fight for LGBTQ equality and equity.
Now, the results from last evening's election certainly, certainly could shift much of this landscape.
I'm sure we'll hear more about all of this from our speaker here shortly.
Imani Rupert-Gordon leads the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, or NCLR, and since 1977 has remained one of the nation's most influential legacy advocacy organizations, striving to advance LGBTQ civil and human rights through litigation, policy, and public education.
Imani said that they were a nonprofit law firm.
Never thought those words could go together.
And it's critical, the work that you are doing.
As a nonprofit public interest law firm, NCLR litigates precedent-setting cases in the trial and appellate court levels, advocates for public policies, provides free legal assistance for LGBTQ people, and conducts community education on LGBTQ issues.
From fighting discrimination in areas such as sports, employment, and healthcare, to advancing racial and economic justice and advocating for LGBTQ youth and families, NCLR works across so many, so many critical areas of impact in our communities.
Imani's leadership is rooted in intersectional justice and recognizes how race, gender, and economic inequality shape the lives and experiences of LGBTQ people, really all people.
Through her work, she brings an important firsthand perspective on the current landscape of advocacy, policy, and public discourse surrounding LGBTQ civil rights nationwide.
Imani has served as the president of NCLR since 2020.
Before stepping into this role, she served as executive director of Affinity Community Services.
She was on the ground doing the work as an LGBTQ social justice organization dedicated to honoring and uplifting the experiences of Black LGBTQ women.
Today, Imani will unpack the current legal and political landscape for LGBTQ rights and discuss the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead.
Challenges and our opportunities that lie ahead.
Good afternoon, and thank you so much for the invitation.
I want to thank the City Club.
Cynthia and your entire team, you've been so wonderful.
I also want to thank Plexus.
Thank you for the amazing introduction, Amanda.
That was so, so thoughtful.
And Jenny, it's so great to, to be working with you again.
My name is Imani Rupert-Gordon, and I'm the president of the National Center for LGBTQ Rights.
We're a legal organization, and we work to achieve and advance civil and human rights for LGBTQ people and our families.
It's not only an honor to be in Cleveland with you today, but coming back here is actually a bit of a homecoming for me.
Me because my parents fell in love here and I was actually born in Cleveland.
We moved when I was young, so I don't have many stories from my time in Ohio, but I'm gonna tell you a story that my mom would often tell me.
When I was a baby, there was a time that we ran out of milk during an Ohio winter.
It was snowing and the car wasn't running, and my parents had a 1-year-old and no milk.
So my mom stayed with me and my dad walked to the store in the snow.
When my mom told the story, it was an epic story.
My dad was the superhero.
When my dad confirmed it, it was barely a story at all.
He'd shrug and say, what was I gonna do?
You needed milk.
I guess they were both right.
My dad was a superhero.
But he didn't think what he did was remarkable.
And for the rest of his life, I watched him show extra compassion to any parent who he met who was struggling.
And I thought about that story recently when I heard JD Vance tell a story of his own.
He described a trip to the emergency room with his kid, and he noticed that there were interpreters that were available for people that didn't speak English fluently.
And for a reason I still don't understand, the point of his story wasn't how grateful he was that those interpreters were there.
He didn't imagine the terrifying experience of being in a situation where you would be worried about your child and not being able to understand the doctor.
In that moment, his concern was, why doesn't everyone just speak English?
It's a tale of 2 Ohioans, my dad and J.D.
Vance.
The difference between them can be measured in empathy, and that's what I want to talk to you about today.
Over the past year and a half, there's been attacks against LGBTQ community, and they have been hateful, and they've been relentless.
We've seen a barrage of anti-LGBTQ executive orders, orders that ban transgender service members from the military and strip them of their retirement benefits.
Or attempts to move incarcerated trans women from men's facilities to women's facilities.
And some of these executive orders are just cruel.
You know, I actually want to get this right, and it looks like this wasn't printed correctly.
Let me just grab my phone.
I want to make sure that I get this right.
Okay.
And these executive orders are just cruel.
The military is the largest employer in the country, and for most people in the country, healthcare is provided by their employer.
So a ban on service is a ban on employment, but it's also a ban on healthcare as well.
And this makes this an issue of economic justice, but also of health justice.
And this also makes it an issue of access to benefits and the access of benefits that we owe to our clients.
We also know that protecting transgender women from being moved out of women's prisons into men's prisons will protect them from an enormous risk of violence.
We know that trans people in prison are sexually assaulted at nearly 10 times the rate of the general population of people assaulted in prison.
But those executive orders did more than what they claimed to on their face.
They also came with cruel rhetoric using people as political wedges.
They came with political ads aimed at transgender kids and a resurgence of slurs and insults that came with them.
This all came with a danger that is harder to articulate.
They were taking aim at our rights, and it's possible to focus solely on the legal -- it's possible that we could focus solely on the legal attacks that we're seeing, but there's something that's much more deeper and insidious that's going on.
Because just asking the question, whether everyone deserves equal rights and access, just by driving the wedge and trying to transform transgender into a dirty word.
That did the work for them.
Just by treating the use of a painful slur as an issue of freedom of speech.
They were engaging in a subtle culture war and changing what we have come to expect and allow.
When we get used to this type of question over and over again in different contexts, it's when we become desensitized to discrimination.
Even the inquiry hurts us.
So questions like, is it okay for trans people to get medically necessary healthcare?
Or is it unfair if trans people play sports?
Or if trans people can serve in the military?
Or are entitled to the benefits that they've earned.
All of these are dangerous because if we question long enough or we engage in a discussion deeply enough, then it's easier to actually treat this question as a legitimate one.
But just the question is both offensive and oppressive.
But here's the thing.
These aren't actually real questions, at least not the questions we think they are.
These questions aren't designed to be about healthcare or sports, not really.
That's why we see all of these attacks happening at the same time, all at once.
A few years ago, trans athletes played sports with no problems and no fanfare.
Healthcare for trans people was given using standards of care like healthcare that everyone receives.
There wasn't a trans military ban.
It doesn't matter whether or not this attack against trans people is a coordinated one, because it functions as though it is.
And when people continue to pose these questions, looking for answers, they contribute to this cycle without realizing that they're doing it.
And like a machine, it starts to run by itself.
And the more we hear these questions, the more we get used to it.
And while the question is posed about being about healthcare or sports or access, the question that's really being answered is about deserving.
Does this person deserve the access and care that we afford everyone?
So even when the answer is a resounding and indignant, of course they do.
The damage is already done because even the inquiry, the question, helps socialize us to a culture where someone's rights are up for discussion.
And this is part of a vicious cycle because once we get used to one group being denied care, it gets easier to deny it to the next group.
If one group can be pushed out of their job because of who they are, then no one has safety in employment.
This starts with trans people, but it doesn't end there.
And it's already started.
The Secretary of Defense, Pete Hegseth, has already said that he doesn't believe that women should serve in combat roles, and he wants to keep people out of positions based on who they are.
And I want to remind you, this isn't a question about your feelings about the military.
This is a question about the right of everyone to have the freedom to hold any job they choose and not be met with a barrier simply because of who they are.
And this is how it starts.
They target one group and another follows.
This is always what happens.
We've seen this before in some of the worst instances of humanity, of human history, and the most sinister examples of humanity.
And we can't let that happen again.
And that's why the story about J.D.
Vance feels so cruel, because the question isn't a question.
He's not asking, why can't everyone speak English?
He's asking, can we single out a group of people based on who they are?
He's saying that some people aren't entitled to understand their child's doctor and invites us to ask whether everyone has an equal right to care.
And we should be outraged by the question itself.
We're here today because of the radical empathy that birthed movements like the civil rights movement, the feminist movement, the Black feminist movement or womanist movement, the LGBTQ liberation movement, and so many others.
We're here today because the people who came before us transformed their outrage over those types of questions into movements that propelled us all forward.
This political moment is our birthright.
We know how to win now because we were bred for this.
We need a culture of solidarity and empathy that too many of our leaders are trying to dismantle.
And they've done it so quietly, and it's so difficult to see, and it's even harder to call out.
And the good news is, is that we get to define our own culture.
And want to talk about some of the things that might allow us to have a little bit more empathy with each other.
So what I'm asking of you, I'm asking you to believe, I'm asking you to commit to something new, I'm asking you to be curious, I'm asking you to imagine.
First, I want you to believe.
In this movement, we too often mistake cynicism for sophistication.
We tell ourselves it's smarter to be pessimistic and surprised when things work rather than being hopeful and disappointed when they don't.
Don't fall for that.
Cynicism is like armor, but it isn't protection when it's hurting us.
Our cynicism is doing their work for them.
The people working to take our rights away don't need to convince us they're right.
They only need to convince us that it's hopeless.
A year ago, how many people would have said that an election could look like it does right now?
And even so, people organized.
They knocked on the doors in the cold.
They talked to their neighbors who disagreed with them.
None of this happens without people who believe that something's possible.
Every right our community has today was once impossible.
Our right to vote was impossible until it wasn't.
Marriage equality was impossible until it wasn't.
The people who won those fights weren't naive.
They knew exactly what they were up against, and they believed anyway.
And that's how we got here.
Secondly, I want us all to commit to reading something new.
Find independent media and use it to supplement everything you read.
A handful of conglomerates own most of what we're told, and they decide what we get to know.
Follow writers on Substack, support nonprofit newsrooms, support international outlets.
NCLR has a Substack.
We can keep you up to date.
I also have some other ones I read if you want.
Verify the things that sound wrong to you and verify the things that sound right.
When a story confirms your worldview so neatly that you can't imagine how anyone could disagree, look for what is left out.
And then read beyond the news.
Read memoirs and novels.
Read the testimony of Black people and people of color, of immigrants and of people with disabilities, of queer and trans people who have stood before state legislatures and explained again and again why they deserve to exist.
Understanding someone's story is one of the oldest empathy-building tools that we have.
And it matters because those questions only work when we don't know anyone that we're talking about.
It's easy to debate whether a transgender teen deserves healthcare when she's an abstraction.
It's much harder once you've read her words and understand that she's a daughter and a sister and a friend with goals and dreams.
And third, I want you to practice being curious.
Too many of our so-called leaders spend time trying to find ways to leave someone out rather than invite people in.
They question who should have to look differently or speak differently or be different in order to be in this room.
And remember, once you ask who you can leave out, you've already decided that someone will be left out.
So I want to offer a different question to a curious person: What would it take for everyone to be included?
And then take it one step further.
The harder step is to figure out how we get there.
Answering that question requires creativity, it requires listening, and a profound amount of empathy.
You may get it wrong the first time, and that's okay.
Because that's the work.
Try until we get this right, to treat the person in front of you as a person to plan for, not a problem to solve.
This is much harder, but if we don't ask our leaders to solve hard questions, then can we really trust our leaders to get us to a place that we want to be?
This isn't easy, but it's one of the most powerful and hopeful things we can do.
Is to decide that what our world can look like when we reach for people and not find ways to eliminate them.
And we know what this takes.
I know that every leader in this room has a story about a time when they took a more nuanced and thoughtful approach to something and got an incredible solution that no one thought was possible.
This is what we should ask ourselves, that kind of vision.
The people that are trying to divide us are counting on us to stop being curious.
They need us to believe that there are only 2 doors, and that way someone will always be on the wrong side.
Don't give it to them.
Be curious.
Ask how, because the question you ask determines how we can build.
And our curiosity allows us to extend empathy outside of the people whose lives match our own.
It makes us easier to see a person rather than an identity.
And finally, we have to give ourselves space to imagine what is possible.
What would it take to create a world where no one has to justify their existence to a legislature?
When a parent walking into an emergency room, whatever language they speak and whoever their child is, only has to worry about their kid?
When medically necessary healthcare for our youth is, is the decision between a young person, their parents, and their doctors.
Where these questions that are meant to divide us sound as absurd to our children and our grandchildren as they should sound to us right now.
We can't build what we can't imagine.
So imagine it, imagine it in detail, and then go build it.
You know, I think back to the story that my mom told me about my dad.
And I used to think my dad shrugged off that story out of modesty.
But I don't anymore.
To him, there was no decision to make.
His daughter needed milk.
The car wasn't running.
The store was there past the snow.
So he walked.
That's what empathy looks like when it's working.
It doesn't feel heroic, it feels obvious.
It's not a debate about who deserves help, it's the absence of the question.
And he never forgot that walk.
He remembered what it was like to be a parent whose child needed something he couldn't easily give.
So when he met another parent in that place, he never had to wonder whether that person deserved help.
Because he already knew.
I feel grateful to have been raised by someone with that kind of perspective.
And that's the difference between my dad and J.D.
Vance.
One of them.
Both stood in the same place, a father afraid, trying to take care of his child.
One came away with more compassion for every parent who could be in that position, and the other came away asking why those parents couldn't be more like him.
We all get to choose what kind of Ohioan or what kind of person we'll be.
There are people who want to keep us busy answering their questions.
Do trans people deserve care?
Do immigrants deserve an interpreter?
Do women belong in combat?
Every one of these questions asks us to stop and debate whether to walk through the snow.
And I don't want us to debate it.
I want us to build a country where it's barely a story.
So let's believe that it's possible.
Let's read so we know what's true and whose stories are being left out.
And let's be curious so you always know a little more about a story that's different than yours.
And let's imagine the lives of people living better lives because of the world that we build together.
And we come to a place that Someone needs us.
Let's put our coats on and walk because what else are we going to do?
Thank you so much.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you so much.
We are about to begin our audience Q&A.
We have our first question.
Yes, ma'am.
Prior to coming here, I did a little research on your organization, and it looks to me like you've done some wonderful work on behalf.
Of LGBT immigrants and refugees.
Can you please talk about that a minute?
Absolutely.
Thank you so much.
So NCLR has a legal and asylum program called Hogar.
It is the oldest LGBTQ legal and asylum program because we started it when it became possible for LGBTQ people to seek asylum in this country.
So it's over 30 years old.
What's happening right now is horrific.
We have done this work for over 30 years.
We have never lost an asylum case.
And under our noses, this process is changing.
And so every day it's changing right now.
We are trying to hire an attorney, and this has been such a long process.
It's so hard to find immigration attorneys right now.
And things are changing.
The asylum offices, they have these -- I mean, there are so many people that -- this is a long process anyway.
When folks are taking asylum, this can be 10, 15, 20 years for some folks.
And now immigration offices are understaffed, intentionally understaffed.
It is harder for folks to just go and go to their hearings.
People feel unsafe going to their hearings.
We've been able, again, we still haven't lost a case and we are putting more resources into that program.
So our clients right now are in the best spot that they can be in.
But it is a very, very difficult time.
Very difficult time.
Yeah.
For years now, it's been very frustrating for those of us who are advocates in Ohio and other red states because we have severe needs for assistance, for litigation, for political contributions, and that money was never spent here.
We were told it's not a good use of the money.
We're gonna have better chances elsewhere.
There have been some times when we have even had local movements try to do things and have been asked by national organizations to step away because that doesn't fit the national strategy.
So given that the presumption that Ohio is a red state seems to have fallen by the wayside on Tuesday, I'm asking you, what should our national leaders of our community be doing to shift the strategy to help those of us who were a lost cause because we were living in the red states?
Yeah, no, that's a great question.
I first want to push back on the idea that you were a lost cause to begin with.
And I want you to know that that's not a shared national strategy.
I understand that there are a lot of people that can only take on cases, they have a very specific way about how to win.
I do think there are people living in lives and living in red states that need support.
And we also know that that doesn't mean that we can't fight.
So that said, I mean, I'd love to actually talk to you and who you're working with, 'cause we would love to work with you.
No matter red or blue, whatever's going on.
I think it's important that national partners, what we can do is provide assistance.
You know what's happening in your state, and we know what's happening sort of broadly.
What we can do is come together and work as partners.
There was just this case, Childs v. Salazar, that came out in spring, and that was the the case that determined how we would regulate conversion therapy.
And we immediately started working with our partners in Colorado to develop sample legislation, but it's them that go and write the actual bills that will work for what happens in their state.
And they were able to pass legislation.
So they already have a conversion therapy ban.
We did this in California.
We're working on some other places.
But after Tuesday, I think there's going to be a lot of support about what this can look like.
Because the other part is, we talk about these things like they're partisan issues.
But conversion therapy bans were passed by Democratic and Republican governors.
So we would be working with folks anyway.
But I would love to just make sure that we stay in touch and see who you all are working with.
This is a text question.
Could you talk about the work of the center?
What cases are you working on right now?
Yeah, great.
So several cases.
So we are a legal organization.
The big thing we do is litigation.
So we are one of the organizations that sues the administration when these anti-LGBTQ executive orders come out.
So far, we've sued the administration 8 times.
And we have several cases we're working on.
So the transgender military ban is one that we came out and started with.
And I think this is a really important one because we're a civil rights organization.
And let me start.
So for all of us to have rights and to do the work that needs to be done, we all need to do well in our lane.
And as a civil rights organization, what has to be most important to us is that if we see that someone can't do something because of who they are, no matter what that is, that is something that is in the realm of work that we do.
And I say that, and I mentioned it in this talk too, because sometimes there are things that folks disagree with, but that doesn't make them not civil rights conversations.
And so The trans military ban is a really important one because it's just stopping people from being trans.
And I will say that a large -- the larger bit of work that we're doing right now is really supporting trans people because, as a good Black feminist, I understand that the most important things that we can do is to talk about the folks that are experiencing the highest levels of marginalization because we know that that's where it starts.
And when we do that, everyone benefits from it.
And so the Trans Military Ban is another -- is one of the cases we have.
But in working with the military, we found out that we developed an expertise.
We made relationships.
So we also have a case where we are supporting veterans who no longer have their retirement benefits or have them taken away for them and for their families.
We have a case where we are protecting some trans prisoners, some trans women that are moving, that the administration is trying to move them from women's prisons to men's prisons because it would put them in so much danger.
One of the reasons we take a case like that is because the cases I mentioned before, those are big cases.
You see those on national news.
But like a Bureau of Prisons case, if it wasn't like an organization like ours and our partners at GLAD Law, that case isn't one that would fall through the cracks.
And so that's another important case that we're doing right now.
The other thing is that there are -- the administration has been sending out subpoenas for medical records of trans kids, secret subpoenas.
Our clients found out on the news that they had been -- that their medical records had been subpoenaed.
And just when we found out, we were able to stop that in less than a day because some of this stuff It's so sinister.
It is so backwards.
And if we're not standing up, then these powers will just go unchecked.
And they're not -- the things that are happening are often not legal.
We're suing a hospital right now who's just stopped giving care to trans people, just stopped giving care.
You can't do that.
It's just discrimination.
There's not another word for that.
So those are some of the cases that we're working on.
How do you feel about people saying that even though we hold a majority, we still haven't won until all of our representatives prove that they will get stuff done and not just fence it?
And how do you think that'll work out?
Can you ask that question one more time?
How do you feel about people saying that even though we have a majority now in the House and the Senate, we still haven't won until our representatives prove that they won't just fence it and will actually get stuff done?
And how do you think that'll work out?
Yeah, I agree with that.
It's a lovely day whenever we have an opportunity to -- I love when people go out to vote.
I love when, during a time that we see that votes are powerful, that's why we see that people try to take voting rights away.
That's why we see the ways that folks try to make it more difficult with changing district and what that, you know, so it's wonderful to see, but the actual work is what happens, like what bills are gonna be passed, like what is the work that's gonna be doing?
And I hope that what people see is that I don't think anyone predicted that Tuesday would look the way that it did, but I hope that means for the people that have been elected that It's time for you to show up for the community that showed up for you.
And so it's my hope that that's exactly what people are going to be doing.
I hope that people look at what's happening and saying, what's happening right now isn't working for a lot of people.
And so I'm going to show up so that I'm helping those lot of people.
Thanks for the question.
I had one.
I'm going to find a way to word this.
But a big thing has been, how do you connect people?
Through their culture?
Because I feel like there's a big, I don't know what's discriminatory, or if something's discriminatory to them, I don't know how it makes them feel because I've never felt it.
So how do you get over that hump of like almost knowing how they're gonna feel about something and being able to put yourself in their shoes better and know like, oh wow, that's how big of a problem is, rather than, oh, it's someone said a word to them that I've never been called before, just kind of putting yourself in their shoes better?
Yeah, I love that question.
I love that question.
We should all be thinking about that a little bit better.
You know, one of the things I said, I will say that I, um, I changed my speech, um, because I thought that it's more important that we think about what is next and what we build.
Um, and one of the things I added there is the importance of reading about stories that aren't yours.
Because that's an easy way to hear a perspective that's not yours.
And it gives you that opportunity to grapple with it on your own and get out some of the things that like, ooh, maybe I should have known that.
It gives you an opportunity to learn those things.
But my favorite way is to build your circle about like with folks that are different than you.
The people that, everyone says there is so much emotional labor teaching people about the most oppressed parts of your dinner.
Your identity.
But the truth is, we do that with our friends.
With our friends, we tell people the things that are hardest.
And so I say, get out there, hear stories that aren't yours, but more than that, build partnerships and communities that aren't yours.
Do you have any specific stories that changed the way you think a lot?
Ooh, the one that comes to mind right now is actually the first time I came out at work.
Like a lot of queer people, I was trying to figure out what that looked like for me.
And basically I came to this place where, as long as I'm not lying about anything, so there's nothing to be done here.
I mean, it was my own, I was having my own trouble with that, but I was also co-instructing this leadership class.
And we asked people to do this assignment about salient parts of their identity.
And it was my assignment.
And it's because I think I was working through something.
And after someone did the assignment the first time, they didn't get it right.
They didn't understand what we were asking.
And so the co-instructors, we got together and were like, well, what can we do here?
And it's like, okay, well, everyone should go and do the assignment and show them what it looks like.
And so now I was in a situation where I had to think about that differently.
And I came out in that class.
It was a longer story.
But in doing so, I developed different relationships with some of the students in the class that were also struggling with some different things that they were going on, that they had going on.
But what was really interesting for me about that is that there's someone that wanted to come out but actually was not ready to and was talking to me about something else and ended up talking to me about her experience with her invisible disability and what that looked like for her.
And that changed my worldview because, you know, whenever you are someone that has privilege in a space, like, it's really easy to overlook the things that you don't see or the things that you don't have.
And I remember thinking that because I was an instructor here.
And so at the time I wasn't thinking, and I was much younger in my career, and I didn't realize how much I could learn from people that were younger than me.
And so that really changed my worldview, but it also changed how I think about mentorship too.
I only have, you know, if I mentor someone, they mentor me as well.
It changed everything, how I think about things.
I'm wondering if you could reflect on how the work of your organization has evolved over the past 10 years with a federal administration that's been so hostile to the LGBT community for the most part, and what you're anticipating the changes might look like going forward as we envision and hope for a more supportive and welcoming administration.
Absolutely.
Thank you.
So I've been at the organization for 6 years, but I was -- I am familiar with the work that we did.
My sister used to run our policy office, so NCLR is kind of the family business.
But over the last 10 years, what -- okay, so I think the -- I'll start at 2020 when I got there.
One of the big shifts was when Biden came into office, and that was in 2021.
When Biden came into office, we had -- one of our cases was the original trans military ban.
And when Biden came into office, all of this work that we are doing, he just ended the trans military ban.
With an executive order.
And so all of a sudden, and we started seeing all these amazing executive orders come out.
And I remember those first 2 months were so great.
We just had all of this free time.
All of this work that we were doing, we could concentrate on something else, which was so amazing.
We also, it's such a, I mean, just a really interesting time.
The Bostock decision came out in '22, I believe.
And that was the decision that said that LGBTQ discrimination was sex discrimination in the workplace.
We saw a lot of really amazing things.
And before that, marriage equality was in 2015.
There was that time, that 8 to 10 year period that was just a lot of things that were really moving quickly for the LGBTQ community.
And when Trump came back into office, Lots of that changed.
The trans military ban, immediately went back up with that.
In that first week, he, I mean, had at least 3 anti-LGBTQ executive orders within that first week.
And that was just really such a difficult, difficult time because we are following up with as much as we can, and all of the legal organizations are, but a lot of this is just a really, it's difficult.
There are more of them than there are of us.
Now, that said, what we're able to do with such a small number of folks is incredible.
That's what organizing gets you.
But what I'm excited about right now is, you know, there's a lot that happened on Tuesday about pro-equality people being elected.
You know, in Texas, trans people can't update their driver's license right now.
You know, we might have some opportunities there.
New AGs and governors that are pro-equality, we have a chance to roll back some of these protections.
You know, there have been several Supreme Court decisions that have been very devastating for the LGBTQ community.
And what that has meant is that so many of the fights are in the states, which is another reason I think it's so important that we work in states, blue or red or purple or whatever color, like, this is where the fight is.
And so I think this is going to really put some wind in our sails because we're gonna have an opportunity to do something that we haven't been able to do in some time.
And I'm really, really excited about what that looks like.
And I know that the president has already said that he's gonna veto everything that comes across.
But honestly, then veto everything that comes across your desk, but let's put everything, everything across his desk.
People should see that we are, that folks are working, that folks care about our communities, and that we're trying to make lives better.
And so I'm really excited about what that looks like.
I think it's going to be, we're going to win this.
We are going to get to the end of this.
We're on the side of justice, y'all.
Sometimes we don't know when these things are going to show up.
We just have to do the work and be happy when they do.
So I'm really excited and really grateful to get to be doing this work right now.
I was just wondering how you think, uh, we, like, as a college club and just, like, in the college university level, should go about, um, still participating in activism and all of that, uh, while our universities are actively trying to defund and kind of chop us down.
I'm so sorry you're experiencing this, and I also want you to know that you are in good company.
This has been -- this isn't -- while it feels horrible, this is not something that's new.
You can always organize on college campuses.
They even expect you to do that, and those are always opportunities.
But something I think, like, you know, we learned a lot from the civil rights movement.
You don't need a school to read the books that you need to learn.
You have a community with you already.
There are things that you all can do and develop your own curriculums around this.
And I think you have to figure out what is it that you're trying to do?
Is your activism so that everyone can have access to get a degree here, or is your activism to figure out What are the people that were, what kind of work were people doing so that we could do the type of activism that we're doing now?
And I think that's such an important thing to think about in this moment, because when we see these attacks on things like critical race theory, if you don't know what critical race theory is, go look it up.
Because the attacks on critical race theory, really all it is is talking about how oppression is institutionalized, how it's structural.
Those of us that have experienced levels of discrimination, we know that that's the case.
But the part that makes it so sinister, and that's kind of what I want to get at here, is that you have people talking about how bad CRT is when actually the idea that we're keeping CRT -- if this was science fiction, this would actually be laughable.
The things that would save us are the things that we would learn in CRT.
The idea that you would keep education out of a university is just the sort of thing that CRT would teach us.
And so I would say the things that they don't want you to learn, that's actually probably, probably the most important things for you to think about, especially when you're young in your activism.
Thank you, Imani.
That was wonderful.
And I really appreciate it also your comment, there are more than 2 doors.
And my question is in the rather sticky area around competitive sports on a certain level.
I don't really have a good answer for people when they come towards me because I myself have some conflicted feelings on the subject.
And so I appreciate, you know, I could go out, I could explore more stories and get an answer myself.
But it is one of those areas that because at this point there are only 2 doors when it comes to, say, competitive sports, it becomes something that's a difficult issue.
Yeah.
So I didn't formulate a question, but I guess I wouldn't know -- I would if there were some way of responding, because of course it's the extreme examples that come up.
Absolutely.
I think that is such a good question.
You're talking specifically about trans people in sports and fairness in sports.
So there's a few things I would say.
And I want to say this as someone who actually cares about a great deal about, about women's sports.
I understand, I understand leadership because of women's sports.
And I can name a lot of WNBA players, not just Caitlin Clark.
So just want you to know, I really, really like Oh yes, I'm also from the Bay, so go Valkyries.
But this is what I would say here.
I'm not here to say what the answer is.
The answer has to be something that works with people.
The NCAA had a policy that trans people played sports with absolutely no problem.
NCLR helped write that policy.
In the 2010s, and it was no problem.
During that time, that's when people were worried about Black masculine-of-center women playing sports, or intersex people, or before that, it was gay men in locker rooms.
So a lot of times, our opponents just kind of find something that they think will stick.
And this just happens to be something that's sticking with a lot of folks.
But the reason I wanted to talk about -- have this talk about how we ask questions and what we're doing with those questions today was actually largely driven by that conversation.
I think that's such an important one.
For as much as we talk about trans people in sports, you would think that there were a lot more of them.
If I spent my time spending my time on something that just impacted such a small number of people, I mean, I wouldn't be able to do my job.
And so I guess my question, what I would say, I would offer a question back.
Why is this the thing that we're talking about when right now there's no trans people in the WNBA or the NWSL?
There's 10 trans athletes in the NCAA out of 500,000.
Washington has 20 student athletes out of over 200,000.
200,000.
Illinois has 4 out of over 320,000.
Utah has 4, 3 or 4.
You know, we're talking about a very small number of people, and that is an outsized amount of conversation we have about it.
Now, I'm saying that because we're having a conversation about trans people in sports when we weren't talking about trans people in sports before, but we're having this during the same time that trans people also can't have healthcare, that we're having a hard time so that trans people can just be in the military or have a job that they want.
I wonder if the question is honestly about sports.
That's my question.
And especially someone who cares about sports quite a bit, for decades, women have talked about not having equal pay in sports, sexual assault in sports, unequal facilities in sports.
There are so many concerns that women in sports have talked about for so long.
And this is coming from people who very often are not the folks that are the most supportive of women.
And so the idea around the question, that makes it hard for me.
Now, that said, if we're at a place where we are talking about fairness, I don't want to stop discussion.
Like, that's not -- everything is up for discussion, and it should be, and it has to be.
Women's sports has benefited greatly because of that type of discussion, but it has to be coming from a place that is honest.
And I'm not convinced that this one is because of all the other things I, I said.
You know, I changed my speech today largely because of this question because it feels like it's a legitimate question.
Is it fair?
Is it like -- but I actually don't think that's the question we're asking.
I think it's just part of one other way to make it harder for trans people to live in public life.
And then once trans people have a hard time living in public life, they're going to pick someone next.
And as a Black queer woman, I feel like these attacks to trans people are very personal, even though I'm not trans, because I know that if it wasn't trans people, it absolutely would be me.
And so I think that these are attacks rather than questions.
But I'm open to having the question if that's what we're doing.
But I also think part of the thing that's amazing about sports is that people are different, and there are going to be people that are different.
And so there's some space there.
But to answer your question, what I do think would be a really important thing to talk about is, even if we don't have the answer, an all-out ban cannot be the answer.
There are some, there are some people that just never go through puberty.
They are working with their doctors and they never go through puberty, and all of the so-called advantages that people say that they have, some people just don't have those.
And so while we are having those discussions, can we not have an all-out ban for anyone to be able to have sports?
I am only standing in front of you right now because I was able to play sports.
My understanding of leadership comes from playing sports.
And that is more than running an organization.
It's more than going to grad school.
It's more than anything at all.
And so I just think that part is so important.
And so make sure that we are asking a question that we're actually looking for the answer to.
And so that's what I would say.
Thank you so much for being here and for all the work you do.
I have a question.
I want to give a little context, and then I'll ask the question again.
But how do we balance progress with stability is my question.
I learned a new word yesterday.
Hope scrolling is what I found myself doing.
I didn't know it, and then I learned the word.
I'm a science teacher, so I'm not ashamed to admit that a former student of mine taught me that 1930s Germany was a liberal democratic republic, and that one of the first acts of a rising Nazi Party was to burn a library in Berlin that was dedicated to sexual research and support and health for trans communities.
So I am incredibly hopeful right now, and I don't want to make decisions out of fear, but I also teach fantastic, inspiring young people, and I have 2 young children myself, and I am -- I simultaneously crave progress and stability.
And so I will repeat my question: how do we balance progress with stability?
Yeah, that's such a great -- that's such a great question.
You know, a couple years ago, nonprofit organizations had a really difficult time, and most people had slashed budgets.
Most organizations had to do some sort of reduction of force and cut activities.
It was just really such a difficult time.
And when we were making these really hard decisions, one of the things that I told our team is that we are going to lean into the things that we do best.
If HRC does it better than us, then HRC's gonna do it.
If Lambda does it better, we're gonna let Lambda do it.
Because what is most important right now is that we provide the greatest amount of support that we can for young people and for our community.
And so when I think about stability, you have to balance what these strategies are.
For me, I love the idea of big swings.
I love the idea that we look out tomorrow And everything that we're fighting for, it is all there in front of us.
We all retire and go on vacation, it's wonderful.
But that's not how, when we look at civil rights history, that's not how things work.
It's not as fun, but things are often built in ways that are just, that are incremental.
And so when I think about the work that we do, I think about building a foundation.
And those are smaller.
There are ways that we include people, but it's a foundation that we can build on.
That we can start over at.
So even when we're pushed somewhere, that we have a foundation.
And so when I think about progress and stability, for me, it's not big swings, the biggest things we can get.
It is what are the strongest things that we can get, concentrating on the things that we do the best.
And so I talked a lot about the work that we do for trans people because NCLR has been doing that for a really long time.
You know, we were created, and some of our earliest work was protecting lesbian mothers who were leaving their relationships and losing custody of their kids.
And that was our earliest work.
But we were serving trans people doing that during a time that other folks in our movement wouldn't even consider trans people or women part of their movement.
And so when I think about the work that we do in building a foundation, it really is making sure that we are inclusive.
That's the thing that NCLR does best.
And so I say, find the things that you do and do them and do them really, really well.
And the other things will build on there.
The last thing I'll say, because I know that we're running out of time, is that it does matter.
Activists and advocates, we are all doing this work.
They act like we are, that we are doing different work, but that's not true.
That is not true at all.
It takes all of us to get here.
If we look at civil rights history, there are people that have been doing this work that we would list like they are people that work together, when in actuality, when they were together, they didn't like working together.
So for us, what we have to do is recognize we have that kind of vision to know that there are people that are doing work that is different than ours, and it's going to take all of us to get there.
Thanks so much.
Thank you once again to Imani Rupert-Gordon and to our members and friends of the City Club.
I'm Cynthia Connolly, and this forum is now adjourned.
For information on upcoming speakers or for podcasts of the City Club, go to cityclub.org.
Production and distribution of City Club Forums by Ideastream Public Media are made possible by PNC and Nordson Corporation.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.
New Episode


New Episode

New Episode


New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
The City Club Forum is a local public television program presented by Ideastream